Effects of chlorophyll fluorescence on the estimation of microphytobenthos biomass using spectral reflectance indices

The communities of benthic microalgae that form dense biofilms at the surface of aquatic sediments, or microphytobenthos, are important primary producers in estuarine intertidal flats and shallow coastal waters. The microalgal biomass present in the photic zone of the sediment is a key parameter for ecological and photophysiological studies on microphytobenthos, and has been routinely estimated using hyperspectral reflectance indices based on the chlorophyll (Chl) a red absorption peak at 675 nm, usually the Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI). This study reports that red region-based biomass indices measured on microphytobenthos biofilms can be significantly affected by the enrichment of reflected light with solar-induced Chl fluorescence emitted by the microalgae. Chl fluorescence emission peaks at 683 nm, counterbalancing the decrease in reflectance centered at 675 nm, thus causing the underestimation of NDVI. The interference of Chl fluorescence was found to be easily identified by a conspicuous double-peak feature in the 670-700 nm region of the second-derivative reflectance spectra. The fluorescence-induced NDVI underestimation was shown to be most pronounced for high surface biomass levels and low incident solar irradiance. Particular aspects of microphytobenthos biofilms, such as the increase in surface Chl fluorescence due the contribution of emission by subsurface layers, and vertical migratory responses by motile microalgae to changes in ambient light, further complicate the effects on biomass estimation using NDVI-like indices. By comparing NI)VI with a fluorescence-independent biomass index for a wide range of natural light conditions, it was found that Chl fluorescence interference may cause the underestimation of microalgal biomass to reach over 25%, with errors above 10% being expected for more than half of the measuring occasions. These results indicate that the use of NDVI may compromise the correct assessment of important aspects of microphytobenthos ecology, such as the characterisation of migratory behaviour or the determination of biomass-specific productivity rates, and call for the use of alternative biomass indices, not based on the Chl a red absorption peak. (C) 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.