Spatial patterns of recruitment in Mediterranean plant species: linking the fate of seeds, seedlings and saplings in heterogeneous landscapes at different scales

1. Plant recruitment is a multiphase process that takes place in environments that are heterogeneous in space and time. In this work, I analyse how environmental heterogeneity in Mediterranean forests affects dynamics of early recruitment at different scales, using the wind-dispersed tree Acer opalus subsp. granatense as a case study. 2. Seed dispersal and viability, post-dispersal predation, seedling emergence and seedling and sapling survival were evaluated in different habitats (regional scale) and microhabitats (local scale). Simultaneously, a review of the literature on spatial dynamics of plant recruitment in Mediterranean systems was conducted to look for general patterns and investigate their fit to the Acer system. Nineteen woody and herbaceous species were included in the review. 3. At the regional scale, Acer recruitment dynamics strongly converged among sites of the same habitat. This was mainly due to large seedling emergence and survival differences among habitats. Although most of the studies reviewed analyzed only one site per habitat type, they also support strong regional variation (either site- or habitat-specific) in recruitment patterns. 4. At the local scale, Acer recruitment was microhabitat-specific, a result shared by almost all the reviewed species independently of their life form and dispersal syndrome. This was mostly due to spatial differences in seed arrival (higher under conspecifics) and seedling survival (higher under nurse shrubs). 5. Spatial discordance among seed rain and recruitment was found in 60% of the reviewed species at the regional scale, and in 67% at the local scale. Acer results supported this predominant lack of concordance. Discordance among seed rain and recruitment suggests that regeneration is largely limited by safe sites than by seed availability. Because seedling survival was the limiting process with a larger impact on the magnitude and spatial pattern of recruitment, safe sites might be defined as those where seedlings have a higher survival probability. 6. Synthesis: This study indicates that the influence of seed dispersal on the spatial patterns and demography of plant species could be limited in heterogeneous and stressful environments (as are found in the Mediterranean), where recruitment is restricted to a small fraction of the landscape. If we are to preserve the distribution and abundance of Mediterranean species in the face of environmental changes, we need to explicitly consider the strong patch-specificity that characterizes their recruitment process at all scales.