Vibrational quenching of excitonic splittings in H-bonded molecular dimers: The electronic Davydov splittings cannot match experiment

The S-1/S-2 state exciton splittings of symmetric doubly hydrogen-bonded gas-phase dimers provide spectroscopic benchmarks for the excited-state electronic couplings between UV chromophores. These have important implications for electronic energy transfer in multichromophoric systems ranging from photosynthetic light-harvesting antennae to photosynthetic reaction centers, conjugated polymers, molecular crystals, and nucleic acids. We provide laser spectroscopic data on the S-1/S-2 excitonic splitting Delta(exp) of the doubly H-bonded o-cyanophenol (oCP) dimer and compare to the splittings of the dimers of (2-aminopyridine)(2), [(2AP)(2)], (2-pyridone)(2), [(2PY)(2)], (benzoic acid)(2), [(BZA)(2)], and (benzonitrile)(2), [(BN)(2)]. The experimental S-1/S-2 excitonic splittings are Delta(exp) = 16.4 cm(-1) for (oCP)(2), 11.5 cm(-1) for (2AP)(2), 43.5 cm(-1) for (2PY)(2), and < 1 cm(-1) for (BZA)(2). In contrast, the vertical S-1/S-2 energy gaps Delta(calc) calculated by the approximate second-order coupled cluster (CC2) method for the same dimers are 10-40 times larger than the Delta(exp) values. The qualitative failure of this and other ab initio methods to reproduce the exciton splitting Delta(exp) arises from the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) approximation, which implicitly assumes the strong-coupling case and cannot be employed to evaluate excitonic splittings of systems that are in the weak-coupling limit. Given typical H-bond distances and oscillator strengths, the majority of H-bonded dimers lie in the weak-coupling limit. In this case, the monomer electronic-vibrational coupling upon electronic excitation must be accounted for; the excitonic splittings arise between the vibronic (and not the electronic) transitions. The discrepancy between the BO-based splittings Delta(calc) and the much smaller experimental Delta(exp) values is resolved by taking into account the quenching of the BO splitting by the intramolecular vibronic coupling in the monomer S-1 <- S-0 excitation. The vibrational quenching factors Gamma for the five dimers (oCP)(2), (2AP)(2), (2AP)(2), (BN)(2), and (BZA)(2) lie in the range Gamma = 0.03-0.2. The quenched excitonic splittings Gamma center dot Delta(calc) are found to be in very good agreement with the observed splittings Delta(exp). The vibrational quenching approach predicts reliable Delta(exp) values for the investigated dimers, confirms the importance of vibrational quenching of the electronic Davydov splittings, and provides a sound basis for predicting realistic exciton splittings in multichromophoric systems. (C) 2012 American Institute of Physics. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.4705119]