A Rigorous Approach to the Formulation of Extended Born-Oppenheimer Equation for a Three-State System

If a coupled three-state electronic manifold forms a sub-Hilbert space, it is possible to express the non-adiabatic coupling (NAC) elements in terms of adiabatic-diabatic transformation (ADT) angles. Consequently, we demonstrate: (a) Those explicit forms of the NAC terms satisfy the Curl conditions with non-zero Divergences; (b) The formulation of extended Born-Oppenheimer (EBO) equation for any three-state BO system is possible only when there exists coordinate independent ratio of the gradients for each pair of ADT angles leading to zero Curls at and around the conical intersection(s). With these analytic advancements, we formulate a rigorous EBO equation and explore its validity as well as necessity with respect to the approximate one (Sarkar and Adhikari, j Chem phys 2006, 124, 074101) by performing numerical calculations on two different models constructed with different chosen forms of the NAC elements. (C) 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem 109: 650-667, 2009