Collapse of allis shad, Alosa alosa, in the Gironde system (southwest France): environmental change, fishing mortality, or Allee effect?

At the end of the 20th century the allis shad population in the Gironde was the largest in Europe. During the first decade of the 21st century, catches declined dramatically by two orders of magnitude, and a fishery moratorium was implemented in 2008. This deterioration in the status of the stock was confirmed by three independent assessments (abundance of juveniles and of potential and effective spawners). Three hypotheses on the cause of the collapse were examined: (i) an environmental change in freshwater and/or in the estuary; (ii) an increase in marine and/or estuarine mortality; and (iii) the presence of an Allee effect. Changes in flow, temperature, and water quality over the period were inconclusive, but remain a possible causative factor. The instantaneous rate of marine (mean: 0.7 year(-1), s.e. 0.1 year(-1)) and estuarine (mean: 2.6 year(-1), s.e. 0.1 year(-1)) mortalities showed no trend between 1991 and 2003. Nevertheless, the past high estuarine (fishing) mortalities combined with a demographic Allee effect in the reproduction dynamics could explain the population collapse and hamper the stock recovery under the moratorium. This conclusion is, however, tentative as it was not possible to prove the presence of the density-dependent mechanism associated with the demographic Allee effect.