唯一.14 2022-04-11

It seems that an editor added a reviewer, but that reviewer has not responded with any comments. So the editor asked me to make the modifications first.

猪条条 2022-04-11

I submitted to another MDPI journal, and it has been under review for a month. I don't know why, but it feels like the reviewing process has become slower.

biyewansui 2022-04-10

4.10 is still under review, overestimating the speed of the reviewers.

Ding录稿怪 2022-04-10

On March 29th, I submitted my article. As of April 10th, it is still pending review. What's going on? I submitted it for the special issue of Rural and Urban Studies. This is taking way too long...

Yaroslav 2022-04-08

Like your situation, ask for additional reviewers. How many more reviewers do we need to find? Do you have any further updates?

lqx1111 2022-04-07

2022.03.26 submission
2022.03.28 under review
2022.04.07 under review

顺利毕业 2022-04-07

2022.04.05 Posted
2022.04.07 under review
Hope for smooth progress!!!

lqx1111 2022-04-06

Is there any news now?

伪装 2022-04-06

The initial review of this journal is very mysterious and lacks clear standards. It is preferable to choose topics related to environmental sustainability rather than social sustainability. Additionally, the assistant editor of this journal is quite difficult to deal with, so it is strongly advised not to submit high-quality papers as they may be rejected instantly. It is easier to pass the initial review if the paper is written poorly.

退休之前发顶刊 2022-04-06

I think our team is doing a great job, with solid evidence and a complete story. Even the guest editors of the special edition think it's good. I submitted it twice, but it was rejected within three days without even reaching the "under review" stage. I can't believe it. I'm planning to work on another topic that aligns with their sustainable theme and then come back to report. Being rejected is embarrassing.

Kliek_618 2022-04-06

Each revised manuscript is submitted for review within one day. The reviewing process is very fast, usually taking 1-3 weeks. Major revisions are given 7 days, minor revisions are given 3 days, and proofreading is given 1 day.

Kliek_618 2022-04-06

2021.12.28 Submission, Under review
2022.02.07 Reject, Encourage Resubmission after Revisions
2022.02.14 Resubmission
2022.02.16 Revision Request before Peer Review Academic editor's opinion, revisions to be made on the same day
2022.03.07 Major Revisions
2022.03.14 Resubmission, Under review
2022.03.21 Minor Revisions
2022.03.23 Resubmission
2022.03.26 Accepted for Publication
2022.03.28 Final Proofreading Before Publication Only modifications through revision mode are allowed, no annotations or modified sections should be deleted
2022.03.29 Resubmission, Published 7 hours after publication

biyewansui 2022-04-05

Record
Submitted on 3.17
Reviewed on 3.18
Still under review until now (4.5)
There should be a response after the Qingming Festival.

哈哈金 2022-04-05

Three major revisions were made, and one expert's opinion was particularly rigorous. The cover letter for the third time was written at great length, and finally, the applicant was hired.

唯一.14 2022-03-31

On 3.31, three reviewers' opinions were received, two of which were quite positive and one was negative. The editor mentioned that there is another reviewer who is still in the process of reviewing, so it is advised to make revisions accordingly.

kikikiwth 2022-03-30

2022.02.04 submit - Submitted on February 4, 2022.
2022.02.06 under review - Under review since February 6, 2022.
2022.03.30 under review - Still under review as of March 30, 2022.

ice90 2022-03-29

Hahaha, is it that the reviewing process has been slow recently?

混合输入 2022-03-29

3.2 under review
3.29 under review
Shouldn't it be quite fast? Why does it feel a bit long? It's hard to wait.

唯一.14 2022-03-29

3.2 submission, currently showing "Ask for additional reviewer", first time encountering this situation.

lqmao 2022-03-26

You can try submitting to specialized journals. Welcome to submit to the "Industrial Solid Waste Management" special issue.

biyewansui 2022-03-25

It took 10 days to die, which is a bit slow.

shanmama 2022-03-25

I don't care anymore, I have been hired by another journal.

shanmama 2022-03-25

0325 update: It was not submitted for review directly. It didn't pass the editing stage.

acanomist 2022-03-24

I submitted an economics research paper yesterday online. Overall, the journal process was very efficient. Below are the various time points for submission:

Submission 2022-02-25
Under review 2022-02-25
Major revision 2022-03-10
Resubmission 2022-03-14
Pending decision 2022-03-15
Paper accepted 2022-03-16
English editing 2022-03-16
English correction done 2022-03-23
Author proofreading 2022-03-23
Resubmission 2022-03-23
Website online 2022-03-23

biyewansui 2022-03-22

What younger brother is this so concerned about?

shanmama 2022-03-21

Help junior brother record it. An article related to LCA.

220315: pending review.

shanmama 2022-03-21

My junior fellow apprentice has submitted a paper on March 15th, and it is currently pending review.

biyewansui 2022-03-21

I was rejected by the second district before 3.15. Immediately after, I spent over a day making revisions (revised the abstract, introduction, title, and reference format). Finally, on 3.17, I submitted to this journal. Surprisingly, it was sent for external review on March 18. It is currently March 21 in Beijing time, and I still don't know the results. I hope they will give me a major revision and not reject the paper! (My topic, methodology, and data are all good, it's just that the language needs polishing, and the structure is not good enough.)

奶茶不要茶 2022-03-10

I misspoke, it's "Pending review".

奶茶不要茶 2022-03-10

May I ask how long your Under pending will take?