sssswwwww 2023-08-07

Posted on May 22, 2023, Under Review.

宇6881 2023-08-05

I have been under review for 6 days after submitting, but yours is quite fast. It is a sure win!!!

THE_LAST _UNICORN 2023-08-05

6.6 under review
7.28 awaiting recommendation
8.2 under review
What is the probability of not being rejected after the first review?

zzzhhhttt 2023-07-26

Hello, I am currently in the third review stage. I submitted it the day before yesterday, but today I suddenly discovered a typo (in the contribution section), although the description and experiments below are correct. Will it be rejected? I am very anxious...

SCI点评专家 2023-07-21

First review RR, 3 and a half months, 4 small peer reviews, all comments are very tricky; revised for over two months, second review took 2 months, directly accepted (AC).
TSG is a top journal in the field of electric power, hoping to be given a chance for revision in the submitted work as well!

Wrigley 2023-07-02

How many reviewers do you have, please?

中中中 2023-07-01

Revisado y reenviado 5.14
En revisión 7.1

两只小绵羊 2023-06-20

2023-6-8 SUBMITTED
2023-6-8 under review
2023-6-19 Admin Reject-Scope (Jun 19, 2023)
The EIC said that my work is more inclined towards power electronics and inverters, rather than the impact on the power grid, so it was rejected. It's a pity, as I actually thought smart grid was quite interesting.

为梦想而生 2023-06-10

3.29 under review translates to "3.29 currently being reviewed."
6.7 accept without changes translates to "6.7 accepted as is."

12312321liu 2023-06-09

6.6 Submission
6.8 Format issues were returned for modification by the assistant editor, and resubmitted on the same day.
Wish me good luck QAQ.

张涛-tju 2023-05-10

Wait patiently for the result.

为梦想而生 2023-05-09

This basically means that once it reaches the editor-in-chief, there is no need to panic, and the results will be available around the weekend.

中中中 2023-05-09

Submit 3.28
Under Review 4.2
Awaiting Recommendation 5.6
Under review 5.9
Revised and resubmit 5.14
Under review 7.1
Awaiting Recommendation 7.25
Under review 7.26

Translation:
Submit 3.28
Under Review 4.2
Awaiting Recommendation 5.6
Under review 5.9
Revised and resubmit 5.14
Under review 7.1
Awaiting Recommendation 7.25
Under review 7.26

为梦想而生 2023-04-22

This basically means that once it reaches the editor-in-chief, there's no need to panic, the results will be out in the next two days.

HF 2023-04-20

Hello, my current status is "under review", which changed to "awaiting recommendation" after two months, but then changed back to "under review" again after one week. According to online sources, this could be due to conflicting opinions from the reviewers, leading to the addition of a new reviewer. I see that you are also in a similar situation. Did you encounter any difficult opinions from the initial reviewer? Did they also add a new reviewer in your case?

为梦想而生 2023-03-27

The text "3.27 revise and resubmit" is already in English.

为梦想而生 2023-03-02

1.9 Under Review: This phrase means that something is currently being evaluated or examined.

Cruise_sun 2022-12-24

2022.6.21 Submission
2022.9.14 First review completed, five reviewers, 23 questions
2022.11.13 Returned for first round of revisions
2022.12.23 Second review completed, accepted without changes

KeSun 2022-12-21

Already accepted. The overall review speed is improving, slightly faster than the first time, although it took over a year with three rounds of revisions throughout.

ZXNzxn1 2022-11-22

Record of Dr. First Manuscript Submission

leoleo 2022-11-12

Thank you to the journal editor and the expert reviewers! This is the second time in high school! The submission timeline is as follows:
(1) 05/04/22: Initial submission of the paper;
(2) 05/11/22: Rejected after initial review: the editor pointed out issues with the expression of the paper;
(3) 05/20/22: Resubmitted after making modifications based on the initial review comments;
(4) 08/09/22: First round of revise and resubmit: there were a total of four reviewers, each with around 10 questions. Some questions were difficult to answer, some required explanations, and others needed additional simulations. Additionally, there was a request to modify the introduction, body, formulas, and overall structure of the paper. The reviewers truly demonstrated their expertise by identifying many issues in the content and expression! So, I carefully consulted relevant literature, replied to each comment diligently, and incorporated the explanations into the paper. Finally, I asked other members of the research group to read and help with the overall manuscript, aiming to eliminate any language and formatting issues.
(5) 09/29/22: Returned for revision after the first review; the revised manuscript and modification explanations combined reached nearly 60 pages.
(6) 11/12/22: Accept; upon receiving the email, I felt pleasantly surprised yet also thought that it all made sense. After all, during those days of revising the paper, I worked diligently, carefully read the comments, searched for references, derived and completed formulas, and made necessary revisions. In short, hard work pays off!

为梦想而生 2022-11-12

9.23 Under Review
10.31 Awaiting Recommendation
11.6 Under Review
11.12 Revise and Resubmit
First review with seven reviewers. The reason why it is called a top journal, I guess this is the reason.

Holly-95 2022-11-08

17-Feb-2022 submission
04-Aug-2022 revision
30-May-2022 revision submission r1
04-Aug-2022 revision
26-Aug-2022 revision submission r2
05-Nov-2022 Accept Without Changes

Translation:
17th February 2022 submission
4th August 2022 revision
30th May 2022 revision submission r1
4th August 2022 revision
26th August 2022 revision submission r2
5th November 2022 Accept Without Changes

一蓑烟雨744 2022-10-25

The overall requirements for IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid are quite high, taking over a year from submission to acceptance. It is indeed difficult to get published in top journals, but as long as the initial submission is not directly rejected, it is essential to make serious revisions and polish the paper well, as there is still hope.

温吞的蜗牛 2022-09-19

May I ask how many reviewers are there for you?

大马哈鱼 2022-09-19

May I ask how TSG determines the progress of this submission? I feel like I have no way of knowing if the submission has even been sent for review, as it immediately shows as "under review" as soon as it is submitted.

sunshine9966 2022-09-05

Top journals in the field of electrical engineering have high requirements for the novelty and practical engineering significance of articles. The submission process lasted for a total of 9 months and went through 3 rounds of review before being accepted. I am extremely grateful for the editor's patience during the multiple rounds of review.

05-Jan-2022 submission
27-Feb-2022 revision
25-Apr-2022 revision submission R1
12-Jul-2022 revision
01-Aug-2022 revision submission R2
15-Aug-2022 revision
19-Aug-2022 revision submission R3
04-Sep-2022 accept

The reviewers are generally experts in the field and their opinions were very helpful in improving the article. I would like to express my gratitude to the reviewers and the editor for their professionalism and patience.

ningch 2022-08-27

The official website of TSG does not seem to have clear requirements for file naming, which is different from the requirements of other translation journals. Can any experienced person who has come across this issue please advise me on how to prepare? Maybe I haven't looked in the right place.

jjyifan 2022-08-22

My just submitted paper has changed to "Under review," and after half a month, it changed to "awaiting recommend." Does this mean it's going to be a tragedy? Have you received the results for your paper?

jjyifan 2022-08-22

Excuse me, just finished submitting and the status is "Under review". Two weeks later, the status changed to "awaiting recommend". Is this a tragedy? No external review.