Verified Reviews - BMC Geriatrics
Janet10 2023-03-09
Submitted for 1 year and 2 weeks, I received an acceptance notice. Then, 2 weeks later, it was published online. The initial process was very lengthy, going through 3 major revisions and being reviewed by 3 experts. The first two times had over 20 questions each, while the third round had only a few questions, but one of them was particularly sharp, involving modifications to the title, abstract, and results. I did not accept this suggestion, but instead argued my reasoning. Fortunately, it was ultimately accepted. Overall, I felt the editor and reviewers were very serious, so you cannot be careless either, but you should stand your ground on important matters.
helenokay 2023-01-18
I have been submitting for half a year, why is it still under peer review?
张小一 2022-11-06
May I ask what does it mean when it says "Editing Assigned" on my screen all the time? It has been like this for 3 months.
搬砖Zing 2022-11-02
Mid-July, submitted;
Received two opinions at the end of August, not many but quite detailed;
However, rejected by the editor in early October.
Create your own webinar
Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.
Create NowAsk a Question. Answer a Question.
Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.
Get Started