Janet10 2023-03-09

Submitted for 1 year and 2 weeks, I received an acceptance notice. Then, 2 weeks later, it was published online. The initial process was very lengthy, going through 3 major revisions and being reviewed by 3 experts. The first two times had over 20 questions each, while the third round had only a few questions, but one of them was particularly sharp, involving modifications to the title, abstract, and results. I did not accept this suggestion, but instead argued my reasoning. Fortunately, it was ultimately accepted. Overall, I felt the editor and reviewers were very serious, so you cannot be careless either, but you should stand your ground on important matters.

helenokay 2023-01-18

I have been submitting for half a year, why is it still under peer review?

张小一 2022-11-06

May I ask what does it mean when it says "Editing Assigned" on my screen all the time? It has been like this for 3 months.

搬砖Zing 2022-11-02

Mid-July, submitted;
Received two opinions at the end of August, not many but quite detailed;
However, rejected by the editor in early October.