Verified Reviews - SIAM JOURNAL ON SCIENTIFIC COMPUTING
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

winterfell 2022-09-16

Can work together as a team

chimezie 2022-09-06

May I ask if this magazine has corresponding authors and if it is possible to have co-first authors?

chimezie 2022-09-06

Excuse me, does this magazine have corresponding authors? Can multiple authors be listed as first authors?

winterfell 2022-07-12

Overall, the experience was quite pleasant. I submitted two articles, one of which was rejected after the first review and I submitted it to another journal. The other article was accepted after minor revisions, and the review process was smooth. The first review took about 2-3 months to receive a decision, and the accepted article took approximately 5 months from the initial submission to acceptance.

木一小P孩 2022-06-11

This journal is almost the best in the field of computational mathematics (of course, there are also the three major journals in computational mathematics, SIAM Numer. Anal., Math. Comput., Numer. Math., which focus more on analysis). There are not many journals better than it, such as SIAM REVIEW and ACTA NUMERICA. If you are working on computational fluid dynamics, computational physics, and related areas, CMAME and JCP are also very good top journals.

In terms of difficulty of publication: SIAM REVIEW and ACTA NUMERICA > SIAM Numer. Anal., Math. Comput., Numer. Math. SISC > CMAME, JCP. To my knowledge, these are the best top journals in the computational field. If there are any other recommendations, they can be added.

Unfortunately, after submitting the manuscript, it took 6 months for a minor revision and a rejection. The editor-in-chief rejected the manuscript because the numerical examples were not done well. After making revisions, it was submitted to CMAME and accepted. I hope to have the opportunity to submit to SISC again in the future.

math315 2022-02-04

One of the top-tier journals in the field of computational mathematics; the best journal in the field of scientific computing; high demand for innovation in numerical methods and analysis. If not directly rejected by the editor, the first review process takes approximately 4-6 months, and the second review process takes approximately 2-4 months.

IGA 2021-03-29

The standard of this magazine is still a bit low. Basically, scholars from the domestic computational mathematics community have their papers published in this magazine, and the difficulty level is far lower than that of the traditional three major computational mathematics magazines.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started