Verified Reviews - PROCESS SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

德德小K 2021-10-10

9.20 Submit
9.21 with editor
9.25 Under Review
10.10 Under Review

Translation:
9.20 Submit
9.21 with editor
9.25 Under Review
10.10 Under Review

杜Nature 2021-10-07

May I ask how long after will you be online?

杜Nature 2021-10-05

2021.7.21 submitted, under review in just two or three days.
2021.9.11 major revision.
2021.9.16 revised.
2021.9.29 minor revision.
2021.9.30 revised.
2021.10.5 accepted.
The processing speed is very fast, it's a good journal.

Z 2021-09-16

The major revision was submitted and received directly. In the past two months, the efficiency has been very high. Indeed, it is a good journal.

7.10: Submission
7.12: Under review by editor
8.18: Required reviews completed
8.25: Major revision
9.10: Revised submission
9.13: Under review by editor
9.15: Accepted

Z 2021-09-13

Here is the translation:

Record the updates:
7.10 submitted
7.12 under review by editor
8.18 completed required reviews
8.25 underwent major revision
9.10 revised submission
9.13 under review by editor

老边 2021-09-12

General major renovations need to be reviewed again.

Z 2021-09-07

Replying to [evi乔], twenty days is quite a long time. Mine was delayed for a week. I suggest emailing if it's been over a month.

老边 2021-09-05

Research papers usually take about two months to yield results. In general, the review process for review articles is usually longer.

blue 2021-09-02

8.27 acceptance, lasting for 5 months.

Augus 2021-09-01

2021.6.10 major revision, but only a few suggestions were made, mainly to revise sentences, without touching on the methods and conclusions.
2021.6.25 Uploaded revised manuscript.
2021.7.28 It took another month to become "under review" with the editor.
2021.7.28-present It is still "under review".
It seems that everyone else's process is relatively fast, but the editor and reviewers for my paper are quite slow. Each "with editor" stage takes at least a month. I hope for good luck.

Augus 2021-09-01

2021.6.10 major revision, but only a few suggestions were made, just need to make some changes in the sentences.
2021.6.25 uploaded the revised manuscript.
2021.7.28 became under review one month after "with editor".
2021.7.28-present still under review.
It seems that everyone else's process is faster. The editor and reviewers for my article are taking longer. It usually takes at least a month for "with editor". I hope for good luck~

evi乔 2021-08-29

Hello, it has been twenty days since I completed it and there has been no progress. Should I send an email to inquire about it? Thank you.

Z 2021-08-25

8.25 Major Revision

Z 2021-08-24

7.10 submit - Submitted on July 10th
7.12 with editor - With editor on July 12th
8.18 Required Reviews Completed - Required reviews completed on August 18th

老边 2021-08-14

There should still be someone who promised to review the manuscript, and their feedback will come back soon. Originally, the editing plan required two reviewers to complete, but now we are waiting for the opinion of the third reviewer.

blue 2021-08-10

The review status changed to "required reviews completed" and two days later it changed to "under review" (after submitting the revised manuscript); does this mean that new reviewers are being sought for the review process?

blue 2021-08-10

Posted on April 3rd, the article was returned by the editor for revisions and resubmitted.
Under review since April 21st.
Major revision on May 12th, with 6 reviewers. 5 revisions were made, and one rejection.
Submitted on June 25th.
Under review since June 28th.
Major revision on July 12th, with 4 reviewers. Two minor revisions were made, and one acceptance (by the same reviewer who rejected it last time). The editor requested a major revision. Additionally, out of these 4 reviewers, 3 of them were not the original reviewers.
Submitted on July 26th.
Under review since July 27th.
Required reviews completed on August 8th.
Currently under review (as of August 10th).
I want to ask everyone, after two major revisions and three external reviews, why is it still being sent for external review?

Guoliang Wang 2021-06-26

Translated text:

Received on March 8, 2021
Revised on May 17, 2021
Accepted on June 22, 2021
Available online on June 24, 2021

Janson-lu 2021-05-25

3.21 submit; 3.23 under review; 4.7 under review; 4.10 under review; 4.27 Required Reviews Completed; 4.29 Major revision; 5.15 submit revision; 5.17 with editor; 5.21 accept

Exactly two months, quite fast.

轻快1 2021-05-24

It seems not that fast, ah. Who is the chief editor of your manuscript?

Augus 2021-05-24

Entered Under Review on 2021.4.17 and there has been no change until now. It has been three months since submission until today.

轻快1 2021-05-24

What is the current situation now?

Academic rookie 2021-04-25

2021.01.31, submitted;
2021.02.18, revised;
2021.02.28, revised submitted;
2021.03.09, accepted;

The direction is in the field of safety risk analysis. The editing process is very fast, and the reviewers are also very professional and efficient. They ask very professional questions! The journal has great potential.

固执的7-11 2021-04-12

Sent in September, received first-round comments in December, second-round review in January of the following year, third-round review in February, and hired in March.

寻觅 2021-04-07

Hello, has your major revision been submitted for review again?

Janson-lu 2021-04-02

How many reviewers? Why was it rejected?

Njust 2021-03-26

Several reviewers

麦麦爱嘟嘟 2021-03-26

Three months, rejected, sigh.

麦麦爱嘟嘟 2021-03-19

2021.1.1 Submission
2021.1.4 Under review
2021.1.13/2.8/3.1/3.17 Status updated 4 times
It has been almost 3 months, and it is still under review
Has it received feedback from all four reviewers? Does anyone know? It's worrisome.

Augus 2021-03-16

20210221 - Submitted to PSEP
20210223 - Sent back to author (Editor requested revision of the introduction section and cover letter)
20210226 - Resubmitted
20210301 - Under editor review

It has been over a month since it entered the "with editor" status. It has neither been assigned to an editor nor invited for review. It seems slower compared to other classmates' submissions. Is it currently experiencing delays? This is my first time submitting to this journal, hoping for a positive outcome~

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started