Verified Reviews - PROCESS SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

chenzzz 2022-11-25

The journal is so fast, accepted within 1 month, great speed!!

Faerie1 2022-11-24

How long did it take for you to submit for review?

可可西里的豺狼 2022-11-18

Less than 3 months
Submitted on August 30, 2022
Major revision on October 20, 2022
Revised submission on November 17, 2022
Accepted on November 18, 2022
Thanks to the editor and reviewers.

hero 2022-11-18

So slow.
9.17 submit to journal
9.21 with editor
10.21 under review
11.8 RRC

张野治 2022-11-07

Hello, which editor processed this so quickly?

Taqiangrentaqiang 2022-11-05

The journal has a wide range of topics, and the editing process is very fast. Its impact factor has been increasing every year, making it worth investing in. However, every time a submission is made, the chief editor Khan sends it back, requesting a stronger literature review on the journal in the introduction before it can be sent for review.

天坑坑主 2022-11-01

May I ask what field you are in? The speed of article review is so fast!!!!

莫名独具 2022-11-01

submitted: 10.3
with editor: 10.5
under review: 10.6
rrc: 10.16
rrc: 10.17
rrc: 10.18
major revision: 10.18
with editor: 10.27
under review: 10.28
rrc: 10.30
rrc: 10.31
accept: 11.1

The given text appears to be a timeline or status update related to a submission or review process.

莫名独具 2022-10-31

Did not receive the track.

呵呵哒 2022-10-31

Did you all receive the track link after "Under Review"? How long did it take to receive the track link?

莫名独具 2022-10-27

Sorry, but I am unable to provide a translation without the actual text that needs to be translated. Can you please provide the text you want to be translated?

YYYezt 2022-10-26

Do you know what is the required rate of similarity check for the initial review of a journal?

花曦 2022-10-21

Can we add each other as WeChat friends? My WeChat ID is LCXX0516. Let's discuss. There are too few people around me who invest in this...

花曦 2022-10-21

Do you actually have four reviewers? You're quite fast... I see more than two reviewers displayed, but only one review opinion is returned... I sent an email to the corresponding author's email address, and they asked me to make major revisions. After your major revisions, do you need to resubmit?

莫名独具 2022-10-20

Daxiu did not send an email. I saw it on the submission interface. I am one of the four reviewers.

花曦 2022-10-20

Did you make changes based on the first reviewer's comments, then send it back and also send it to the second and third reviewers?

花曦 2022-10-20

I would like to ask, did your suggestions for the major revision mention the possibility of resubmission after modification?

花曦 2022-10-20

I don't know why I only have one reviewer, I don't know if I will continue to submit for review.

花曦 2022-10-20

I am in the same situation as you. I also had a major repair yesterday.

花曦 2022-10-20

Your progress is about the same as mine.

hero 2022-10-19

Currently, PSEP does not have a peer review tracking feature.

莫名独具 2022-10-19

submitted: 10.3
with editor: 10.5
under review: 10.6
rrc: 10.16
rrc: 10.17
rrc: 10.18
major revision: 10.18

Translation:
submitted: 10.3
with editor: 10.5
under review: 10.6
rrc: 10.16
rrc: 10.17
rrc: 10.18
major revision: 10.18

@#238 2022-10-03

May I ask if you have sent the "Track Your Elsevier submission" to the corresponding author when your paper is under review?

夜枫之舞 2022-10-03

How is the above content displayed in the submission system to indicate that one review has been returned and another expert has agreed to review?

终于吃饱了 2022-09-14

It's really fast, only took one month. Thank you to the editor and reviewers.
2022.8.7 Submitted (with editor)
2022.8.13 Under review
2022.8.29 Required reviews completed
2022.8.31 Major revision
2022.9.12 Submitted revised manuscript (with editor)
2022.9.13 Under review and accepted in the evening!
Wishing everyone smooth scientific research!

Vincent_mfy 2022-09-08

July 4, 2022 - Submitted to journal
July 4, 2022 - With editor
July 15, 2022 - With editor
July 16, 2022 - Under review
July 24, 2022 - Under review
Aug 02, 2022 - Under review
Aug 05, 2022 - Under review
Aug 15, 2022 - Under review
Aug 24, 2022 - Required reviews completed
Aug 25, 2022 - Major revision
Aug 31, 2022 - With editor
Aug 31, 2022 - Under review
Sep 05, 2022 - Accept

lehang 2022-09-06

2022.June 21 Submitted to Journal;
2022.August 9 Minor revision;
2022.August 18 Revision received;
2022.August 26 Accept.

Translation:

On June 21, 2022, the article was submitted to the journal. On August 9, 2022, a minor revision was requested. On August 18, 2022, the revised version was received. Finally, on August 26, 2022, the article was accepted.

Vincent_mfy 2022-09-04

May I ask if there was no second review sent to the first reviewer after the major revision?

乱世巨星 2022-09-04

Will send to the first-instance expert.

Vincent_mfy 2022-09-03

May I ask if it is necessary to resend the revised draft to the previous reviewer for confirmation after submission?

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started