矫情的小书 2021-06-25

Posted on March 31, 2021, received review comments on April 26, returned the revised manuscript on May 17, received second round review comments on May 28, returned the revised manuscript on June 7, and received an email notification on June 19. The overall speed is very fast! The review comments are very professional! However, I heard that the online process is relatively slow, so I hope it can be expedited! The timely impact factor is around 7.9, the journal is truly developing at a rapid pace! It's great!

没事看文章 2021-06-24

How many days does it usually take to reach the editor's hands? Mine has also been submitted all along.

jgj 2021-06-20

Excuse me, is there a result now?

Qin 2021-05-28

Be careful not to choke on the Northeastern rice while eating. Annoying people like you. Regional discrimination is too far-fetched. Even a little bit of technical knowledge, I wouldn't be able to insult you.

小洋 2021-05-27

After submission, the manuscript was reviewed one day later. The status was updated several times, indicating that the manuscript has been continuously processed and reviewed by different reviewers. It seems that within a month, the reviewer's comments came back. There were minor revisions and major revisions (although there were no substantial changes). Moreover, the first reviewer seemed irresponsible, as he only reviewed the paper after requesting language modifications. The editor directly rejected the paper. After revising it according to the reviewer's comments, especially modifying the language, I resubmitted it. However, it felt like it didn't even reach the editor's hands and was directly rejected without any reason given. I have submitted many papers before, to various journals, but my impression of this particular journal is not particularly good. This is only my personal feeling and should be taken as a reference only.

磕磕绊绊 2021-05-22

It's been almost a week and it's still in the submitting status, why is it so slow?

c101821 2021-05-07

Industry professionals all know that even for top-tier journal ACTA in the field of metals, there are many influential connections. One can determine the level of articles published in ACTA by looking at the research groups of the editors and the articles they publish each year. Whether ACTA can publish an article mainly depends on the editors, and at the very least, there is a moderate probability of acceptance.

c101821 2021-05-07

Both reviewers are quite conscientious and responsible, but one of them has limited expertise and raises relatively elementary questions. The other one is a top-notch expert in the industry, with meticulous and professional questions. The journal is good, and we hope it will continue to improve and surpass Acta soon.

lythu 2021-04-28

After confirmation, the status is also "manuscript submitted".

材料人人 2021-04-25

After submission, do all authors need to confirm? It has been several days already, and it has been continuously stated as "manuscript submitted".

材料人人 2021-04-25

Do all authors need to click confirm?

材料人人 2021-04-25

Do I have to click "confirm" to reach the reviewer?

大聪明Z 2021-04-24

Journal submission is about relationships, not specifically about the relationship between this journal and people from Northeast China. If you don't like it, you don't have to submit to this journal. Please do not put on colored glasses and make comments about people from Northeast China.

qishenmene 2021-04-22

Many of the submissions to this journal are from acquaintances. The annual number of submissions is not high, and many are already pre-determined. Usually, if a paper is rejected by JAC or MSEA, it is submitted here. For those who value the current impact factor and division, it may be worth a try. Although efforts are being made to improve the quality of this journal, the relationships in Northeast China still play a significant role. I hope the editor will pay attention to the future development of the journal and not let relationships ruin it.

超越自己 2021-04-12

Does this magazine require payment after accepting submissions?

科研可言 2021-04-12

Has been under review for 22 days, should I write a letter to the editor to inquire about the progress?

microlong 2021-04-06

Submitted in the morning, rejected in the afternoon, the reason being that there were too many submissions, I give up.

好好干科研啊 2021-03-31

Has this problem been resolved? Does everyone need to click the link and confirm in order to complete the submission and send it for review?

好好干科研啊 2021-03-31

Has this problem been resolved? Do all co-authors need to click the link to confirm in order to complete the submission and send it for review?

做奋斗的鱼 2021-03-23

Go and search for the journals on carbon materials that you guys work with, there are a bunch of journals that are even better than Carbon. Go and search for the journals on metallurgical engineering and see where JMST stands.

做奋斗的鱼 2021-03-23

Go and search for the journals on carbon materials that you guys work with. There are plenty of journals that are even more awesome than Carbon. Go and search for the journals on metallurgical engineering and see where JMST is positioned.

倪雨朦 2021-03-15

One major repair and one minor repair, taking three months to complete.

一条小鱼 2021-02-28

Ah? Can I contact you at 1098549756?

固执的北极熊 2021-02-24

Share the process of submitting an overview article:
2020.11.10 submitted
2020.12.14 major revision
2021. 01.10 resubmission
2021.02.08 minor revision
2021.02.10 resubmission
2021.02.14 accept
There were two reviewers, both quite professional. One of them raised 34 questions, which amounted to 2000 words, so the first major revision took a long time. Recently, I have been paying attention to this journal because it is listed as a first-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences. This journal is more inclined towards articles on metals, but occasionally accepts research from other popular fields. Our overview focuses on the research progress of 4D printing, which is considered a new field with an increasing number of publications in recent years.

一只工科女 2021-02-16

so stupid! Ignorant and foolish.

一只工科女 2021-02-16

Can you please stop talking nonsense? Do you understand carbon? Do you know about it? Have you invested in it? Carbon is the top magazine in our charcoal industry. Please do not insult it and mind your choice of words!

小玮大论文 2021-02-12

Did your thesis ultimately get accepted?

柯基飞不动 2021-01-28

Recently received, the approximate cost after typesetting is 500 pages. I also only found out after receiving that I need to pay publication fees.

09123790 2021-01-26

Domestic users are charged approximately 500 RMB per page. The total cost should be based on the final publication.

月亮在笑 2021-01-20

Boss, may I ask if we need to reply to each comment in the Reviewer report document after the repair?