Verified Reviews - Journal of Materials Science & Technology
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

peipeipeiper 2022-05-10

Excuse me, classmates who have passed the course, does the content in supporting also count as page fees?

东南小明王 2022-05-05

It's not considered malicious defamation. Many people have suffered losses in this journal, and there are indeed quite a few articles of poor quality.

唐伯虎点蚊香 2022-04-28

Our revised manuscript was not submitted for review for a month after it was submitted, but finally, after a reminder, it was sent on the same day.

化学搬运工 2022-04-26

Please help with the Endnote format for this journal. Thank you, respected expert. Wishing you success in your submission.

搅局的圣徒 2022-04-25

The original text translates to: "Just like the original poster, I submitted the modifications on April 19th, but it hasn't been reviewed yet as of April 25th."

never reject 2022-04-24

4.14 minor revision
4.20 submitted revised manuscript
It has been 4 days and it is still "Revised Manuscript Submitted"
Is this normal? How long does it usually take to receive acceptance after submitting revisions?

backseven 2022-04-22

A few teachers collaborated and submitted a review article, which was fortunately accepted. JMST is definitely a stable first-tier journal in China. It was submitted in December 2021 and the DOI number was published online in April this year. The process was quite fast. The requirements for the content of the article are relatively high.

龙之弄 2022-04-17

What is a reference? I couldn't find it online.

778899catalysis 2022-04-16

The development of JMST is indeed impressive. It is estimated that in the near future, investing in JMST will become a pursuit and trend for technology workers, just like pursuing AM currently. Keep up the good work!

创新之祖 2022-04-16

This magazine has recently started to accelerate its development. Whether it's the quantity and quality of articles, impact factor, or publication speed, it's all rising rapidly, just like riding on a high-speed train. The quality of the articles doesn't seem to reach above 12 points, so I don't recommend submitting to this magazine. The editorial department has very strict control. Additionally, it seems that the magazine has released many high-quality special issues, significantly enhancing its academic influence. This magazine, along with two other magazines, Nano Research and Science China Materials, are known as the three pillars of the Chinese materials field. Currently, this magazine and Nano Research have both surpassed 10 points. Chinese materials journals are charging forward!

l384346393 2022-04-13

It is becoming increasingly difficult to publish articles now, as the journal impact factor continues to rise and the quality of articles is also improving. The review process is still quite fast, with results typically being available in a little over a month. I hope the journal continues to improve!

药尘枚 2022-04-05

Just want to ask, has your current condition changed?

大弟仔 2022-04-02

2022/3/31 Decision in process
2022/4/2 Decision in process
It is estimated that the content of the article does not align with the journal's requirements, so rejection can be understood, but the process is also too slow.

大弟仔 2022-03-31

2022/3/26 Manuscript Submitted
2022/3/31 Manuscript Submitted
The speed is so slow...

Never rejected 2022-03-15

The front desk rejected it, and the next day it was rejected again...

biubiu侠 2022-03-14

22.1.14 submission;
22.1.15 under review;
22.2.6 received reviewer comments, minor revision, only given 3 days, requested extension until 3.15 via email;
22.3.10 submitted revised manuscript;
22.3.11 under review;
22.3.14 accepted.
Overall, the process was quite fast, especially considering that the revision came during winter break, which delayed it for over a month.
The reviewers were all very nice. The editor was efficient, sending it for review the next day on both occasions.
I submitted my inorganic materials to a top journal in the field of metal materials, and initially worried it would not be reviewed. However, to my surprise, it was handled promptly, proving that not all domestic journals are slow or of inferior quality.
Looking forward to JMST's continued success.

呵呵那个大 2022-03-04

This journal is managed under a publication fee. Payment is based on the number of words and images.

jqxky 2022-02-26

0119 submitted
0209 minor revise
0218 revision submitted
0226 accept
The speed is very fast, worthy of praise!
But why did they say they will email me to pay the publication fee for the paper later? Isn't it non-OA? I don't know if it's expensive or not...

呵呵那个大 2022-02-18

I also received 5000 this month and feel uncomfortable.

现代舰船 2022-02-15

It's okay, let's take a detour. There are plenty of high-quality journals available now, there's no need to bring humiliation upon ourselves.

现代舰船 2022-02-15

You are overthinking, even if you don't have any connections in the editing department, do you still think you can make it?

Cadi 2022-02-15

Then I'm screwed. Mine is also "with editor" and now it changed back to "manuscript submitted"....

Jing Nikki 2022-02-14

It means that you don't have to open access, it is not mandatory for you to do so. How much do you have to pay for page fees?

潇洒哥 2022-02-05

My layout fee is 7000, with 6800 words and 13 images.

催而化之 2022-01-21

JMST is developing very well and has a recent increase in the number of published articles. I heard from friends before that they value article quality, so I chose to submit a relatively high-quality one, and sure enough, it was accepted. Innovation is the most important. The online speed is very fast, changing my perception of domestic journals. There are good jobs ahead, so I will continue to submit to JMST. Nowadays, JMCA, SMALL, and ACS AMI have all become second-tier journals, but JMST is standing strong. It is striving to increase its impact factor to above 15. When that happens, I believe everyone will choose JMST over AM. Keep going, JMST! Push forward!

biubiu侠 2022-01-16

Posted on 22.1.13,
On 1.14, it showed "under view". I don't know if this is the current status after submitting, or if it has indeed been sent for review. I am anxiously waiting.

绿色催化 2022-01-15

JMST has developed rapidly, with such a large number of publications, and it can still maintain such a fast impact factor growth rate. This is truly remarkable. I believe that in the near future, JMST will become a leader in the materials industry and a representative journal of domestic production. It is estimated that the impact factor will be above 10 next year, so make sure to submit before the impact factor is released in June.

会飞的辰鱼 2022-01-08

It is necessary to charge a fee. The number of pages in my work is around 20, and it costs 4000 yuan. This is not considered high, as many domestic journals charge fees, some of which are even higher than this.

会飞的辰鱼 2022-01-07

2021.10.13 Manuscript Submitted
2021.10.21 With Editor
2021.10.22 Under Review
2021.11.11 Under Review
2021.11.17 Decision in Process
2021.11.25 Revisions
2021.12.06 Revisions Submitted to Journal
2021.12.06 Decision in Process
2021.12.14 Accepted

This manuscript submission to JMST brought me some unexpected joy. Firstly, I saw many comments saying that the reputation was not good, which made me a bit worried. Secondly, our teacher knew an editor who we were not very familiar with, and he said that JMST currently did not need papers in our field, and told me to quickly prepare for another journal. I was also preparing for other journals, but unexpectedly, it was sent for review after two days. Therefore, I advise friends who are submitting papers to still have faith in domestic journals, enhance the innovation and language fluency of their papers, and not always blame journals with malice. This submitted paper also did not have any editor I knew, and the peer review indeed took quite a long time, but relatively speaking, it was still fair. JMST journal currently holds a considerable influence in the field of materials in China. Let's support domestic journals and hope for continuous improvement!

xtrnn 2022-01-04

2021.10.9 submit - Submitted on October 9, 2021.
2021.11.8 major revise - Major revision required on November 8, 2021.
2021.11.22 revision submit - Revision submitted on November 22, 2021.
2021.12.2 accept - Accepted on December 2, 2021.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now