xsa6913 2023-05-14

Open thread testimony
5.15 Submission With Editor

sb滚出China 2023-05-12

5.12 A reviewer's comments came back, minor revisions.

电催化研 2023-05-12

May I ask if it was directly accepted after being reworked and sent for review for more than ten days with the editor?

电催化研 2023-05-12

with editor for 8 days

电催化研 2023-05-12

After the minor repairs were completed, it was still with the editor on the same day. Is this situation quite dangerous? It is too slow.

blqk 2023-05-10

In the reply from the corresponding author that you found, there is a dynamically updated link. That link allows you to see the under review process, which involved inviting 2+ reviewers. It also shows the dates when some of the reviewers received the manuscript for review and when they submitted their review comments. All of this information is continuously updated.

blqk 2023-05-10

Do pictures need to be uploaded separately?

hua` 2023-05-10

Hello, I would like to ask if the "under review" date in your submission progress has changed or if it has only been updated once?

电催化研 2023-05-09

Mine is also this, the editor gave a minor revision.

blqk 2023-05-09

Record:
Submitted on 3.29
With editor on 3.29
Under review on 4.2
Required reviews completed on 5.1
Interim Decision on 5.7
There were two reviewers, and their comments were not extensive. However, the editor's response in this state is indeed rare. Let's make the necessary modifications.
Also, in the editor's response this time, it was mentioned multiple times that the images should be uploaded as separate files. Does everyone do it this way? Can't we just directly include them in the body of the Word document?

blqk 2023-05-09

Do I need to upload the images as separate files after this journal is returned for revision?

blqk 2023-05-09

Does anyone know if the final manuscript of this journal needs to have the images uploaded as separate files? Usually, can't they just be included in the Word document?

sb滚出China 2023-05-06

What's the situation with you guys now, bro?

sb滚出China 2023-05-06

5.6 still under review, feeling very uneasy.

hua` 2023-05-06

Brother, have you received the comments on the manuscript?

紫宸-小小 2023-05-05

5.2 Major revision: Four review comments were given, and the editor requested a major revision within one month.

紫宸-小小 2023-05-05

5.2 Major Revision

Dustl1ght 2023-05-03

4.24 Submission
Reviewed by editor on the same day
4.30 Decision in process
5.3 Decision in process, feeling discouraged
5.3 Suggested to resubmit, seems hopeless

sb滚出China 2023-05-02

How's the situation now, OP?

sb滚出China 2023-05-02

5.2 The status is still not updated and remains under review.

孤独幽紫 2023-05-02

January 5th RRC

光催化菜鸟 2023-04-29

3.20 Submitted, same day with editor
3.27 Received three review comments, editor suggested major revisions, one month given
4.18 Submitted revised manuscript addressing review comments
4.25 Minor revisions made
4.26 Manuscript accepted
The editor's handling speed of the manuscript is still very fast, hoping JCIS will continue to improve.

oldkitty 2023-04-29

Posted on April 19th, and until today, April 29th, it is still "with editor". I don't know what's going on. Are there friends who are so slow?

浅夏初凉 2023-04-27

March 13 major repair, April 19 return for repair. May 3 middle.

回到通过 2023-04-27

May I ask what is the final result? I submitted it yesterday at 4 pm, and 8 minutes later it went directly to the editor. 5 hours later, it went directly to "Decision in process." Does this mean it will be rejected?

回到通过 2023-04-27

May I ask what the final result is? I called at 4 pm yesterday, and 8 minutes later, I was directly connected with the editor. 5 hours later, it said "Decision in process". Does this mean it will be rejected?

sb滚出China 2023-04-27

4.27 under review

sb滚出China 2023-04-26

4.19 提交
4.19 与编辑者
4.26 与编辑者

Translation:
4.19 submit
4.19 with editor
4.26 with editor

紫宸-小小 2023-04-26

Submission Experience:
3.29 submitted
4.2 under review
4.5 under review
4.10 required reviews completed
4.15 required reviews completed
4.21 required reviews completed

guhai 2023-04-26

4.19 submit/with editor: This means that the document or work is ready to be submitted to or reviewed by the editor.
4.26 with editor: This indicates that the document or work is currently being reviewed or edited by the editor.