Verified Reviews - IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Pubsuccess 2021-12-07

Dual-column template
Link: https://pan.baidu.com/s/1x7VN1dWTn0gtatcq7lNlSA
Extraction code: qaoo

Pubsuccess 2021-12-07

The review process is quite fast.

Pubsuccess 2021-12-07

Nov 21 2021 12:37PM Manuscript ReSubmitted
Nov 24 2021 1:39AM With Editor
Nov 24 2021 12:00PM Under Review
Nov 29 2021 12:25PM Decision in Process
Dec 2 2021 2:59PM Accept

Translation:
Nov 21 2021 12:37PM Manuscript ReSubmitted
Nov 24 2021 1:39AM With Editor
Nov 24 2021 12:00PM Under Review
Nov 29 2021 12:25PM Decision in Process
Dec 2 2021 2:59PM Accept

Pubsuccess 2021-12-07

Oct 3 2021 11:55PM - Under Review
Oct 4 2021 9:41AM - Under Review
Oct 5 2021 3:31AM - Under Review
Oct 5 2021 2:01PM - Under Review
Oct 6 2021 2:00PM - Under Review
Oct 9 2021 1:48PM - Under Review
Oct 15 2021 1:28PM - Under Review
Oct 21 2021 2:26PM - Under Review
Oct 23 2021 1:49PM - Under Review
Oct 27 2021 3:32PM - Decision in Process

光学小硕 2021-12-07

It's really unbelievable. I have already submitted it for a month, but the "Under Review" time keeps changing every few days. I don't know if the moderator has received any feedback.

phoebe0978 2021-12-06

I submitted my article on 11.11, and it became "witheditor" on 11.16, and it is still the same now. On 11.22, they asked me to change the format once, and after I made the changes and sent it on 11.24, the editor replied with an email saying they received it, but it has not been reviewed yet.

wengangtian 2021-12-06

May I ask what information is required for Geolocation information? Could you please provide a template? Thank you.

风之小翼 2021-12-06

My two experiences were: required reviews completed in one day, decision in process in one day, quite fast.

来自深海的小鲤鱼 2021-12-03

Hahaha, you are so fast! It has been two weeks since I completed the Required Reviews, how scary.

风之小翼 2021-12-03

Visual measurement algorithm made
Submitted in early July
Received major revisions after 28 days, with four reviewers, three of whom provided comments, mainly on experimental rigor (setting new ground truth, adding new criteria), and requested the addition of comparative algorithms (added 4 new ones). Some suggestions were made for the algorithm (tried several improvements based on suggestions, but no improvement in performance, explained in the response and discussed in the main text).
Submitted revised manuscript within 3 weeks
Accepted after one month, all three reviewers expressed satisfaction
A few days later, sent the paper materials, but received an email after about a month saying they did not receive the materials...probably due to the attachment being too large (40MB), resend
A few days later, early access, then proofreading and payment
Overall, the process was fast and the experience was good
Wishing everyone an early acceptance.

sanctitude 2021-12-02

Please carefully read the hyperpage agreement. If you are a student, register as a member of this association (of course, you must first register as an IEEE student member). The membership fee is approximately over one hundred Chinese yuan in total, and then you can have the overpage fee waived.

夏光明 2021-12-01

Can you please provide the process for reviewing the manuscript, OP?

风之小翼 2021-12-01

The extra page fee is really expensive, 265 USD. I exceeded 7 pages.

darren_heu 2021-12-01

I replied wrongly. That, I think it depends on your research direction to determine the speed. As for me, I have to be quite fast.

darren_heu 2021-12-01

TIM magazine's work attitude and speed are excellent, very satisfactory, truly a conscientious publication.

Mz.DAFA 2021-12-01

Don't panic, the editor has been busy celebrating Christmas recently.

lst2333 2021-12-01

I submitted the manuscript on November 9th, and it changed to "with editor" on November 15th. It is still "with editor" at the moment. Do any brothers who have submitted before know what the situation is? Why is it taking so long...

hit林海 2021-11-25

3个月哈三个月 translates to "3 months, ha, three months" in English.

cluo 2021-11-25

When will the latest partition be released?

hit林海 2021-11-25

2021.08.28 submitted
2021.08.29 Modify the format
2021.09.04 under review
2021.10.07 required reviews completed - Three reviewers, one suggested acceptance, two suggested revisions, and the editor also provided modification suggestions, requiring major revisions within 20 days.
2021.10.30 with editor
2021.10.31 under review
2021.10.09 required reviews completed - The second reviewer provided some modification suggestions, requiring minor revisions within 10 days.
2021.10.22 under review
2021.10.23 accept
Submitted to acceptance, overall less than two months, self-revision was quite slow, mostly submitted right before the deadline. The efficiency of the editor and reviewers was very high, and their suggestions were also very professional. The first SCI paper went relatively smoothly, I wonder if it can be published in the Chinese Academy of Sciences Journal (Zone 1) haha.

justice0407 2021-11-17

Thank you for sharing, this text has given me a lot of confidence! I wish everyone a smooth submission of their papers!

Jun 30 Initial Date Submitted
Jul 4 Under Review
Aug 28 Required Reviews Completed
Aug 29 Major Revision
Sep 19 Revised Manuscript Submitted
Oct 4 Under Review
Oct 19 Decision in Process
Oct 20 Accept

sanctitude 2021-11-14

2021.11.13 WOS retrieval, the retrieval is quite fast. But it would be even better if it was half a month earlier, as the scholarship could have been upgraded.

科研小菜鸡 2021-11-09

Manuscript Submitted - Nov 4, 2021 2:46AM
With Editor - Nov 8, 2021 9:41PM
Decision in Process - Nov 9, 2021 7:24AM
Sending "Liáng Liáng" to myself, it seems that the scope of the journal does not match, but I have no choice if the boss wants to submit it. I will try to make it more relevant next time before submitting.

pegn 2021-11-03

The email will be written.

soooooou 2021-11-03

The original text is 9 pages long, and the major revision was given 21 days.
The first reviewer questioned the originality, and the third reviewer was a peer who asked many questions.
The revised manuscript increased to 10 pages, and the response letter is 10 pages long.

soooooou 2021-11-03

Aug 8, 2021: Submitted
Aug 12, 2021, 7:35 AM: With Editor
Aug 16, 2021, 10:43 PM: Under Review
Sep 27, 2021, 1:18 PM: Decision in Process
Oct 19, 2021, 7:32 AM: Revised Manuscript Submitted
Oct 21, 2021, 2:54 AM: With Editor
Oct 22, 2021, 6:08 AM: Under Review
Nov 1, 2021: Accept

清神 2021-10-22

Have you published it after hiring? How long does it take from hiring to publishing?

ZHAO J C 2021-10-22

In total, it took about two months. There was a delay of about half a month in the middle, but ultimately, I was hired. The process was very fast, and it is my first SCI publication. I hope IEEE TIM will continue to improve and thrive!

超师傅 2021-10-19

1. The first round of review rejected and resubmitted.
2. The second round of review changed reviewers and required major revisions.
3. The third round of review was accepted directly, with the original reviewer.

一白丁 2021-10-19

7.24 submit
7.26 with Editor
8.3 under review
9.3 required review completed
9.7 decision in process
9.12 major revision
9.13 resubmit
9.17 with Editor
9.21 under review
10.11 required review completed
10.15 decision in process
10.15 accept

Translation:
7.24 - Submitted
7.26 - Under review by Editor
8.3 - Under review
9.3 - Required review completed
9.7 - Decision in process
9.12 - Major revision required
9.13 - Resubmit
9.17 - Under review by Editor
9.21 - Under review
10.11 - Required review completed
10.15 - Decision in process
10.15 - Accepted

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started