Verified Reviews - IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON CONTROL SYSTEMS TECHNOLOGY
被拒稿yyds 2022-06-07
Please remind the editor, as it is possible that they are overwhelmed with a large number of manuscripts.
被拒稿yyds 2022-06-07
The outcome is that the thesis, which has been through many twists and turns, has not yet been submitted for review after nearly six months.
被拒稿yyds 2022-06-07
I urged for an update and was told that due to various reasons, the manuscript has not been sent for review yet. They asked me to choose another senior editor to handle the manuscript, as it is possible that the chief editor is overwhelmed with many papers during the transition to a new review system.
kaka 2022-05-31
It has been 10 months, and I have not received the first trial. I feel very helpless!!
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-31
It's fine to remind him, but it seems like Kaka has already been reminded. It has been over ten months, and I don't know if he has received the first-instance opinions.
鲍媛媛 2022-05-30
Can you urge the submission? It's too slow. What should I do? Please give me some advice.
鲍媛媛 2022-05-30
Regretting being too slow. Thinking of urging the draft and then withdrawing it. Is there any other way?
鲍媛媛 2022-05-30
Mine is also particularly slow. Does it affect the progress? Can I urge for the manuscript? I'm considering withdrawing it. I'm in a hurry!
鲍媛媛 2022-05-30
Ah! I'm also anxious. It's too slow! Can you please hurry up the manuscript? Seeking guidance. Thank you!
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-24
@xu_11 How long have you been waiting for your submission? I have a feeling that the first review might take about a year at this rate. It's been more than 5 months since it was received, and there doesn't seem to be any progress.
xu_11 2022-05-24
It's too slow, I'm ready to withdraw.
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-23
So helpless.......
kaka 2022-05-23
A few days later, it will be 10 months, and there is still no first trial.
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-22
Has anyone received the reviewer's comments for this year's (2022) submission? It has been five months for me, and it is still marked as "Received".
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-13
The editor-in-chief made the decision to change the peer review system for the journal. Only the editor-in-chief can make the selection. When did you submit your manuscript? It has been nine months and I have not received any feedback on the review yet. My current status is still "Received."
xujinhuan 2022-05-13
I want to ask the author which editor they submitted to. It's been five months and still no news, feeling a bit anxious.
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-10
I checked the latest articles published in TCST. The speed is as follows. It has been almost five months for me, and it is still "Received". So slow...
The manuscript was received on August 28, 2020; revised on February 17, 2021; accepted on April 30, 2021.
The manuscript was received on April 19, 2020; revised on December 5, 2020 and April 1, 2021; accepted on May 5, 2021.
The manuscript was received on August 5, 2020; revised on March 22, 2021; accepted on May 15, 2021.
The manuscript was received on October 6, 2020; revised on January 9, 2021; accepted on May 25, 2021.
The manuscript was received on November 6, 2020; revised on March 30, 2021; accepted on June 4, 2021.
The manuscript was received on September 16, 2020; revised on April 7, 2021 and June 1, 2021; accepted on June 4, 2021.
被拒稿yyds 2022-05-02
The journal is too brutal, the review process took 9 months.
kaka 2022-05-02
It has been 9 months, still under review.
被拒稿yyds 2022-04-22
I don't know if I can withdraw the submission. It seems like the journal has gone out of business, and there is no news at all.
Chacha 2022-04-22
Can I apply for withdrawal of the manuscript?
被拒稿yyds 2022-04-20
Suddenly regretted submitting to this journal. It seems that it will take close to a year to receive the review comments.
被拒稿yyds 2022-04-20
It is an automatic reply when submitting contributions. Mine is now also four months old and still "received".
kaka 2022-04-20
The speed is incredibly slow. It has been 5 months since receiving the application and it is still under review. Another 4 months have passed and it is still under review. In 10 days, it will be 9 months and there is still no feedback from the first review.
wqeqewqwwe 2022-04-19
Is this an automatic reply for recent manuscript reminders?
被拒稿yyds 2022-04-17
Hope cannot directly be followed by a noun as an object, but it can be followed by "for" and a noun to express a achievable "hope".
Automated reply from the editorial department: We hope to process the submission within the next three to four months.
It has been almost four months, and my paper is still in the "Received" status. I feel like the editorial department should use "wish" instead because "wish" expresses something that is difficult to achieve.
被拒稿yyds 2022-04-08
Hello, OP, have you received the reviewers' comments on your article?
被拒稿yyds 2022-03-23
Extremely slow, it has been three months this year and still only received.
名字被吃了 2022-03-22
After submitting my contribution, it remained in the "received" state for about a month, and then it changed to "under review."
kaka 2022-03-22
This journal should be approached cautiously, especially for those who are in a hurry. I submitted to this journal on July 29, 2021, and after three days, I was reminded to resubmit due to a system update. On August 3, I resubmitted using the new system, and the status became "received." It remained in this state until January 18, 2022, when it finally entered the "under review" phase. Currently, it is still in this state, and it is expected to take approximately 9 to 10 months for the first review.
Add your recorded webinar
Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.
Upload NowBecome a Peeref-certified reviewer
The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.
Get Started