junupliu 2021-09-27

Hello, may I ask how long does the decision stage of your second review process usually last? Mine has been 36 days and there still hasn't been any result.

海纳百川，有容乃大！ 2021-09-27

2020-4-29 submitted to journal
2020-4-29 with editor
2020-5-22 under review
2021-5-08 required reviews completed (two reminders in between)
2021-6-01 revise (R1, 5 reviewers, total of 25 comments)
2021-6-28 revision submitted to journal
2021-7-08 sent back to author (no response to section #1: a) and b))
2021-7-09 resubmitted to journal
2021-7-29 sent back to author (correct citation format for references in the text)
2021-7-31 with editor
2021-8-14 required reviews completed
2021-8-30 revise (R2, 2 reviewers, total of 2 comments)
2021-8-30 revision submitted to journal
2021-9-27 accept (reminder sent on the night of the 26th)

chengzhiwen2021 2021-09-20

Most likely, your submission does not meet the requirements for journal formatting or submission.

kaikaile 2021-09-19

Waiting for the editor-in-chief to handle it, it should be the end of the review process.

刘剑东 2021-09-14

One and a half months later, the first-instance trial has entered the "decision in process" stage. Is there a high probability of being rejected?

刘剑东 2021-09-14

2021.07.26 submitted
2021.09.13 decision in process.

Translation:
2021.07.26 submitted
2021.09.13 decision in process.

kaikaile 2021-09-12

The first trial will take approximately three to four months.

爱吃柚子的AI 2021-09-11

You're too amazing, how long does the second review take?

爱吃柚子的AI 2021-09-11

You're so amazing! How long does the second trial take, three months?

小强爱学术 2021-09-11

The time span from submission to receiving the first draft is approximately six months.

努力发SCI的东 2021-09-08

It has been nearly two months since I submitted my work. It was only sent for review yesterday, but I am still happy that it was finally submitted for review! Whether it is accepted or rejected, I appreciate the opinions of the reviewers. Wish myself good luck!

北航小库里 2021-09-05

"Under review" means that it is currently being reviewed or evaluated.

Fighting_z 2021-09-01

Dear experts, my submission has been under review for a while now, and the status keeps getting updated with new dates periodically. Does this mean that the reviewers cannot be found? In such a situation, will the editor reject the submission directly?

kdjsb 2021-08-31

May I ask if you have received any results for your article? Mine has been in the "decision in process" status for almost a month now.

accept 2021-08-25

Thank you, thank you. I received these emails because one of the authors did not verify. It has been resolved now and also reviewed three times. I hope to receive good news soon and I also wish you to receive good news soon.

accept 2021-08-23

The under review process for my third review was quick, it seemed like less than a week. However, the decision in process has been 27 days already. Experts, I would like to ask, is it normal that one of the authors of my paper does not have any information about this paper in their submission system?

happyzyj 2021-08-22

I have not received these emails.
Please log in to your account where you submitted your article and check the status. If it says "under review," then just wait patiently. If it says "decision in process," then it means the editor is making a decision. In my case, the "under review" status lasted for over twenty days, and the "decision in process" status lasted for over twenty days as well, almost a month, before I received the acceptance notification.

accept 2021-08-21

Excuse me, but may I ask a question, sir? I submitted my revision for the third review on July 26th, and today is already August 21st, but I still haven't received any updates. During this period, I received emails from the receiving editor, associate editor, and publishing editor. Is this situation normal? How much longer do I need to wait to receive the results?

accept 2021-08-21

Excuse me, esteemed professionals who have already accepted, I had my third revision on 7.26, and today is already 8.21, but I still haven't received any news. During this period, I have received emails from the receiving editor, associate editor, and publishing editor. Is this situation normal? How much longer do I need to wait to receive the outcome?

Drlau 2021-08-11

There is a small question that needs clarification, which is whether the reply letter section should also be included in the revised manuscript?

Drlau 2021-08-11

Oh, okay, okay. Thank you very much, kindred spirit~

happyzyj 2021-08-11

Section #1: You can separate it into a) email content, and b) your reply to the editor-in-chief.
Other sections 2 and 3 are similar.

Drlau 2021-08-11

Brother, may I ask how to handle this section in the response? Please help clarify.

section #1: a) and b)
a. the entire editorial decision letter (i.e., complete text covered in this email letter) from editor-in-chief, and
b. your responses to editor-in-chief.

Drlau 2021-08-11

Brother, may I ask how to handle this section in the response? Please help me understand. Section #1: a) and b) a. The entire editorial decision letter (i.e., complete text covered in this email letter) from Editor-in-Chief, and b. your responses to Editor-in-Chief.

Drlau 2021-08-11

Brother, how should we deal with this section in the response? Please enlighten me.

Section #1: a) and b)
a. The entire editorial decision letter (i.e., complete text covered in this email letter) from Editor-in-Chief, and
b. Your responses to Editor-in-Chief.

happyzyj 2021-08-08

Submission period: 2020.10.10--2021.8.7
For the first review, two reviewers provided favorable comments, and the decision was given within two to three days.
For the second and third reviews, an additional reviewer was added, and the decision was given after waiting for approximately one month.

liying1118 2021-08-06

Hello friends, I would like to ask whether we need to upload the version with tracked changes when submitting the modified document. I couldn't find the option to submit, so do we only need to upload the final version? I'm seeking answers from my friends, it's urgent~

liying1118 2021-08-06

Hello, do I need to upload a version with tracked changes when making modifications, or do I only need to upload the final modified version?

liying1118 2021-08-06

Hello, may I ask if it is necessary to upload a version with track changes when making modifications, or is it sufficient to only upload the final modified version? I couldn't find a place to upload versions with track changes.

accept 2021-08-05

Hello, I would like to ask how long it takes for a "decision in process" to change to "accept" or "reject"?