泣小雨 2022-08-13

Excuse me, the original poster, I haven't been able to find a reviewer for three months now. Will I be rejected if I can't find one?

Farmer98 2022-08-13

During this period, two reminders were sent for the manuscript. The email for manuscript submission reminders can be found on the journal's official website.

Farmer98 2022-08-13

2022 3 10 submitted 提交 - Submitted
2022 3 15 submitted 修改格式后提交 - Submitted after formatting modifications
2022 3 21 under review - Under review
2022 6 22 under review 日期更新 - Under review, date updated
2022 7 08 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed
2022 7 25 major revision - Major revision
2022 8 01 revision submitted - Revision submitted
2022 8 03 revision submitted 只能上传一个manuscript - Only one manuscript can be uploaded for revision
2022 8 05 revision submitted 只能上传一个manuscript，之前把文件类型改为补充材料也不行 - Only one manuscript can be uploaded for revision, changing the file type to supplementary material did not work
2022 8 09 under review - Under review
2022 8 12 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed
2022 8 12 accept - Accepted
The review process took 4 months, possibly due to difficulty finding reviewers. There were a total of 9 comments from two reviewers, with one suggesting minor revisions and the other suggesting major revisions. The editor decided on major revisions, and the revised manuscript was submitted in less than a week. Fortunately, the revised version was processed quickly. Despite some ups and downs, the outcome was satisfactory.

三叶草2311 2022-08-12

It's been so long, we definitely need to remind them about the manuscript. The reminder email address can be found on the journal's homepage. Only after the revision can we know which editor is handling the journal.

pytorch 2022-08-12

It's really slow. How long have you been doing this? Did you send any reminders? It's been almost 10 months for me.

LuckHAO 2022-08-12

Excuse me, how can I urge the submission for this journal?

LuckHAO 2022-08-12

May I ask how to urge the submission for this journal?

LuckHAO 2022-08-12

This journal's review process is too slow.

pytorch 2022-08-12

Congratulations first, by the way, I have a question. It has been nearly 10 months since I submitted my paper, and the status is still "under review". Does this mean it's a tragedy? Or should I remind them to review it? Who should I contact to remind them? Do you have any experience with this journal?

pytorch 2022-08-12

What is your situation? I submitted my work in November last year and it is still under review as of August. Should I remind them to review it?

三叶草2311 2022-08-11

Literal meaning, the editor asks you to add consecutive line numbers in the manuscript, which can be easily added in Word with a single click.

fish8888 2022-08-10

I received a formatting modification request: "Insert continuous line numbering on your Manuscript file." I'm not quite sure what it means. Can someone please help clarify? Thanks a lot!

三叶草2311 2022-08-06

2022 5 24 submitted
2022 5 27 submitted returned for formatting changes and resubmitted on the same day
2022 5 31 submitted returned for formatting changes and resubmitted on the same day
2022 6 03 editor assigned
2022 6 12 editor invited
2022 6 13 under review
2022 7 02 required reviews completed
2022 7 12 required reviews completed
2022 7 12 major revision
2022 7 29 revision submitted
2022 8 02 editor invited
2022 8 05 editorial decision: Accept
2022 8 15 proof
2022 8 17 online
After major revisions, the paper was accepted without external review and submitted online in less than three months. Overall, it went quite smoothly.

泣小雨 2022-08-05

If we cannot find reviewers for three months, will it be rejected?

self-help 2022-08-05

7.29 Accept
8.3 Proof
8.5 Online

彬彬123 2022-08-05

I would like to ask, what does it mean when the "Under Review" status has been updated? Did the reviewer change?

cyyyyyyyy 2022-08-03

I would like to ask for help from experienced friends. I accidentally uploaded my paper to SSRN preprint when I submitted it to Elsevier before. I couldn't find a way to withdraw it. Now I am submitting to ESPR and they are asking for a cover letter mentioning whether the paper has been previously uploaded as a preprint. Does this mean that the journal does not accept preprints? I am new to submitting papers and I am very worried about graduating on time.

cyyyyyyyy 2022-08-03

Congratulations, basking in good luck~

ziyuguo 2022-07-31

Research Squad is a preprint platform where you can see the status of your submission even if you do not preprint it. After submitting, you will receive the website link in your communication email.

zzzaaaa 2022-07-31

May I ask how to determine whether "under review" refers to the reviewer's side or the editor's side?

fantasy 2022-07-27

Same question, it's been ten days for me too. May I ask how you've been since then?

rs_小逸尘 2022-07-24

Hello, may I ask why I cannot see the status of my submission in the manuscript system for my first submission as a corresponding author? Can only the corresponding author see the status?

my9722 2022-07-22

4.20 Submission
4.24 Returned for modification and resubmission due to cover letter issues
5.31 Minor revisions
6.15 Submitted revised manuscript
6.26 Accepted
7.1 Proofreading
7.3 Online publication

It might have been a coincidence, I didn't expect it to be so fast. Quite lucky, I wish everyone good luck!

LIYJJ 2022-07-22

It has been 10 days since the acceptance. The proof has not been sent yet. Should I remind them? How long did everyone else take to send the proof?

TOMJ 2022-07-21

I want to ask, if there is no email for the editor in the submission system, who should I send the email reminder to?

paper machine 2022-07-15

The homepage has a "Contact" section, where you can find the corresponding editor's email according to your own progress.

三叶草2311 2022-07-13

Latest update
12th July 2022 required reviews completed
12th July 2022 Major Revision
Looking forward to good news ahead

三叶草2311 2022-07-12

It has been ten days and still no news.

超越2022 2022-07-12

The second round with the editor has been 5 days, it's too slow.

Rainmaker 2022-07-11

Update
4.14 Submitted
4.25 Editor assigned (Returned once due to formatting issues)
5.10 Editor invited
5.11 Reviewers invited
5.11 Reviews received
5.29 Major Revision
6.22 Revised manuscript submitted
6.24 Editor invited
6.25 Reviewers invited
6.25 Reviewers agreed
7.9 Required Reviews Completed
7.10 Accept
Both the editor and reviewers handled the manuscript relatively quickly and there were no significant delays.