努力发SCI的东 2021-11-13

It has been over a month and it is still "Required reviews completed". The time has not changed, so it should be waiting for the editor's processing or the reviewer.

zfw 2021-11-13

I would like to ask the original poster which field they are in, why are they so fast? Have they previously applied elsewhere and then modified before submitting here?

zfw 2021-11-13

From submission to under review, it happened so quickly. How is the situation for the original poster now?

zfw 2021-11-13

I would like to ask, could you roughly describe the time points for each of your states? This is for reference, thank you.

zfw 2021-11-13

I want to ask everyone, how long is the review period for this journal? How is the acceptance rate? Please feel free to comment below.

努力发SCI的东 2021-11-09

11/9 2021 still Required reviews completed
Hope to have an article in this journal! It's really a great journal! Major revisions or minor revisions are all blessings!

黄金泽 2021-11-07

I want to ask how much is the layout fee for this journal? I couldn't find the fee information on the homepage.

Fulin 2021-10-21

Brief and concise, no need for various professional terms, just hand it over.

walet 2021-10-09

I want to know how long it takes for your first review under review. Is it going to take a long time if there is no news for almost two months?

sdf41 2021-10-09

My recommendation is also to write a Lay Summary.

walet 2021-10-08

Are you so fast? I haven't received any updates for almost two months (under review). I don't know if it will be rejected or what. Waiting is too difficult.

Dream123456 2021-10-07

May I ask if it is compulsory to submit a 100-word lay summary after the acceptance of the paper?

努力发SCI的东 2021-10-06

Afraid to talk, why did it happen so quickly!
10/6 2021 Required Reviews Completed
I hope there can be some major or minor repairs, hopefully it won't be canceled~, feeling extremely nervous...

努力发SCI的东 2021-09-30

So powerful! I hope everyone will be generous and lenient!
9/23 2021 Submitted
9/29 2021 Under Review
Wishing myself good luck! Also, wishing everyone good luck!

recall 2021-09-26

Summarizing the submission process:
1. Submitted on March 1st, received major revisions after the first review on June 15th. Two reviewers provided very professional feedback.
2. Revised and resubmitted on August 6th, completed the review process on September 24th, and accepted on September 25th.

努力发SCI的东 2021-09-25

9/23 Submitted
9/24 With editor
Send it to me for review and give me some advice, all you international experts!

xiaowei123456 2021-09-17

There is no theoretical restriction. As a reviewer, I can responsibly tell you that in the reviewer options, there is an option to ask "Is the length of the article appropriate?" Personally, I feel that a range of 10 to 20 pages is suitable.

Sanliwa 2021-09-10

Is there a page limit for submitting to this journal?

Fulin 2021-09-01

The quality of the journal article is quite good, although the number of articles per year is not high, the quantity and impact factor are increasing, making it worth submitting. Personally, the review process is quite fast, taking about 4 months from submission to acceptance.

Submitted to Journal on April 22, 2021.
With Editor + Under Review + Required Reviews Completed + Decision in Process, lasting about a month.
Major Revise on June 5, 2021 (given two months for revisions).
Resubmit on June 29, 2021.
With Editor + Under Review + Required Reviews Completed + Decision in Process, lasting about two months (Required Reviews Completed: two weeks, Decision in Process: two days).
Accept on September 1, 2021.

recall 2021-08-26

Return for major repairs in June, return with modifications in August, until August 26th, with editor for half a month.

辣皮子好吃 2021-08-18

Posted in May 2020, major revision given in July 2020.
Replied to major revision in August 2020, minor revision given in November 2020 (only one minor issue).
Replied to minor revision in December 2020, as of August 2021 (present), the review process has not concluded. Sent an email to the editor asking if the reviewer for the minor revision declined due to the impact of the pandemic, as it has been difficult to find a new reviewer. It has been delayed until now.

NPU 2021-07-07

When will we receive the feedback? It has been almost one and a half years since the first trial... Have you given your feedback?

ifengjh 2021-07-06

Are we waiting for the review comments to come back, or waiting for something else?

NPU 2021-07-04

Sent an email, but just asked to wait. Currently, RRC has been ongoing for more than three months.

ifengjh 2021-07-03

Has it been one month since RRC, and has RRC continued for two months? Have you emailed the editor?

NPU 2021-06-29

Not yet, still in the same state. How about yours?

NookLook 2021-06-05

Very good journal, the editor is very responsible and the reviewing experience is excellent. I submitted it in February and received the first round of major revisions within two months. It was "tortured" by six reviewers, some providing comments and some engaging in discussions. After submission, it took one month for minor revisions in the second round (by the end of May), and the acceptance was received the day after one week of modifications.

NPU 2021-06-04

Required reviews completed, it has been two and a half months and still no result. The first review has been ongoing for almost 16 months.

recall 2021-06-01

After my paper was under review, the status date changed three times, but it is still in the under review stage. Does anyone have the same situation? The editor has found several reviewers, = =!

NPU 2021-05-25

Several reviewers, 2 or 3.