xucz 2022-08-29

5.30 - Submitted
6.5 - With editor
7.20 - Still with editor, so I sent an email to urge for the manuscript
7.27 - Under reviewer
8.29 - Still under reviewer
The speed is too slow, I'm crying.

soon_cheer 2022-08-28

There is a guide for authors on the submission interface, which includes some requirements. I followed the rest of it based on the feedback I have received from journal editors in the past.

narutow 2022-08-24

I also want to ask where to find the template for this.

法外狂徒张三93 2022-08-23

The text "delete" is already in English and does not need to be translated.

hujianbang 2022-08-21

Normal, usually changes state in about half a month.

法外狂徒张三93 2022-08-20

2022.08.20 submit - Submitted on August 20, 2022.
2022.08.23 with editor - Under consideration by the editor since August 23, 2022.
2022.9.3 under review - Currently being reviewed since September 3, 2022.
2022.11.2 Reviews completed: 2+ - Reviews completed on November 2, 2022, with two or more reviewers.
2022.11.5 Review Complete, Major Revise - Review process completed on November 5, 2022. Major revisions required.
2023.1.5 Major Revise - Major revisions made on January 5, 2023.
2023.1.18 Accept - Accepted on January 18, 2023.

ulaaa 2022-08-19

May I ask if this journal requires recommended reviewers?

keke1603 2022-08-19

Excuse me, does this journal have any formatting requirements for revised submissions? I've been searching for a while but couldn't find any.

keke1603 2022-08-19

Hello, may I ask if there is a specific format for the revised manuscript of this journal? I can't find a formatting template in the guide for authors.

NookLook 2022-08-18

8.03 R1 submitted
8.04 with editor ---- 8.18
The first review draft is still with the editor, is the editor on vacation?

whiwnl 2022-08-15

2022-08-01 Submitted to Journal
2022-08-03 With Editor
2022-08-13 Under Review

Asked customer service, the editor invited 4 reviewers, and all reviewers agreed to review. Luck is a bit unfortunate.

QAQAQA 2022-08-13

2022.8.7 小修改 - 2022.8.7 minor revision
2022.8.10 重新提交 - 2022.8.10 resubmit

QAQAQA 2022-08-13

After submission, you will receive an email titled "track your submission" with a website where you can track the status of the review process.

keke1603 2022-08-09

I submitted on 7.21, and on 7.22 it was "with editor", and on 7.31 it was "with editor" again. I don't know if the editor has been changed, but currently it is still "with editor".

Fighting_z 2022-08-08

Do any of the brothers have recent submissions? I submitted on July 27th and received a response from the editor on the 29th. There have been no changes since then, and it has been more than ten days. The editor has not taken any action. Does this mean my submission will be rejected?

朝田诗乃 2022-08-04

The status tracking link will only be sent to the corresponding author.

朝田诗乃 2022-08-04

2022.7.12 submit
2022.7.23 under review
During this period, there were four changes in status, and the time for "under review" was updated again.
2022.8.14 major revision
2022.9.02 resubmit
Currently still waiting, hoping for a good result = =

hujianbang 2022-08-03

Who should I send the link to? Only to the corresponding author?

LeyN 2022-08-02

jun 17 submit

I forgot when it became "ur" in the middle.
aug 2 under review

It has been at least over a month since I submitted. It seems like there are really a lot of submissions, so it's probably not going to work out.

sunny-ny 2022-07-28

May I ask how to find out how many reviewers I have?

sunny-ny 2022-07-28

5.23 Submission
6.3 Under review
7.22 The status has changed for a while, but still under review
I would like to ask if the tracking of the review status or notification emails from multiple reviewers will only be sent to the corresponding author?
Because the corresponding author is a teacher, I am unable to view the emails myself.

德累斯顿石头人 2022-07-26

After entering "under review", the editor will send a status tracking link for the review process, and then the number of reviewers can be seen.

stalker 2022-07-24

How can I find out the number of reviewers and their comments?

GG怪叔叔 2022-07-19

My decision is in process and will be made quickly. The results will be out within 2 days, and the editor will make the final decision.

微笑看明天_李宁 2022-07-18

Posted on May 4th, 2022, the intermediate status changed three times and several experts were consulted. It has been agreed upon by two experts for the review.
On July 17th, 2022, the status changed to the editor making a decision.
On July 18th, 2022, the status changed back to under review.
It is estimated that the opinions of the two reviewers did not align, so we are waiting for the third reviewer to make a decision!
I don't know how much longer we have to wait...

hujianbang 2022-07-18

Today I voted, hehe.

三脚猫 2022-07-18

I have been returning for more than 20 days, still With Editor.

微笑看明天_李宁 2022-07-18

Don't you have this process? "Decision in process" means what?

微笑看明天_李宁 2022-07-13

Two review opinions have come back for over a month, but there is still no third reviewer willing to review. I wonder what the situation is.

梦不到的刀塔 2022-07-11

This journal is quite normal. It can be accepted by the editors within one to two months. The length of time for editor processing varies. If it exceeds two months, you can send an email to inquire. The general response is that the editors have already been informed about this matter, and whether it will change or not depends on fate.