xxxt 2021-12-16

The second day has been hired.

kawhi 2021-12-15

2021.12.9 Submission
2021.12.11 With Editor

xxxt 2021-12-15

The second trial opinion came back at 12:15, with a minor modification and one acceptance. It was returned on the same day.

坐在街头看文献 2021-12-12

The text translates to: "Submitted the day before yesterday, assigned a draft number yesterday, and has been with the editor all this time. The email footer displays Swathi Ramalingam/Administrative Support Agent. Can my friends please tell me what this means?"

liu neng 2021-12-11

Don't worry, wait and see. I submitted in late September, and by mid-November, it was still with the editor. Later, I sent an email to inquire about it and received a response saying that they had already contacted the reviewers, but no one had accepted it yet. After about another week, two experts agreed to review it.

xxxt 2021-12-11

It is said that there will be a notification after each review, but I am not quite sure. Only communication can be seen.

GOS 2021-12-11

May I ask, after the reviewers accept the review, will we receive an email notification for each reviewer's completion of the review, or will we only receive a notification after all reviewers have completed the review?

GOS 2021-12-11

May I ask, after the reviewers accept the review, will we receive email notifications for each reviewer's completion, or will we only receive notifications after all the reviewers have finished reviewing?

135467841321 2021-12-09

As long as the reply is not particularly bad and the attitude is not particularly poor, most of the time, the revised version will be accepted. Giving revisions is just one small step away from being accepted.

xxxt 2021-12-08

2021.12.8 Second trial completed, hoping for a favorable outcome.

ZhenZhhi 2021-12-08

2021.11.18 submitted to date (2021.12.8) with editor

香菜味福佳白 2021-12-07

December 7th, Required Reviews Completed

coco 2021-12-06

2021.11.18 submitted, why is it still "with editor" on 2021.12.5? It has been over half a month and it hasn't been sent for review yet. What's the situation?

ZHAO J C 2021-12-06

Thank you for Meng's comment, it has led to a funny article.

Jack111417 2021-12-05

The text roughly translates to: "At the end of November, my submission was rejected within a week, and I was advised to submit it to clean production. I am worried that the content of my article is still different from the theme of clean production. I refused to resubmit it and instead modified the article myself before submitting it again under clean production. Should I have just resubmitted it directly? Would that have been easier to be accepted?"

阿飞 2021-12-05

2021.11.18 submit - Submitted on November 18, 2021.
2021.11.19 with editor - Under review by the editor on November 19, 2021.
2021.12.02 under review - Under review as of December 2, 2021.
期待下一个变化 - Looking forward to the next change.

YUANRUITIAN 2021-12-03

May I ask if receiving three emails indicating that the reviewers agree to review means that this paper will ultimately be reviewed by three reviewers?

YUANRUITIAN 2021-12-03

How many reviewers does CBM generally have? After the paper is under review, I received three emails from the editor (with the same content but different times), all indicating that the reviewers have agreed to review the paper. Does this mean that the paper will be reviewed by three reviewers?

向阳 2021-12-02

Now the official website of CBM cannot be accessed. I would like to ask if there are any experts who have the specifications for modifying article formats. It is my first time submitting an article. Thank you all.

sonny超级萌 2021-12-01

Bamboo seems to belong to the field of civil engineering. Please remember to cite several articles about bamboo from CBM.

平头哥 2021-11-29

Submit the manuscript around September, revise it once, and have it reviewed by three teachers. It will be included by the end of November. Thank you, journal.

kkk58 2021-11-27

Originally, I was so excited about the return of the manuscript. Now, I feel so upset that it is still under review! Ah!... I feel like crying.

不将就. 2021-11-26

I would like to ask, how can we tell from the reply whether the suggestions have been incorporated and accepted for the modified version?

锤子！ 2021-11-26

Received the fourth CBM, the speed is still acceptable.

ZHAO J C 2021-11-26

Hello, may I ask if studying bamboo materials belongs to civil engineering?

ZHAO J C 2021-11-26

November 25th: under review

KevinLau 2021-11-26

Overall, the civil engineering section of this journal is relatively easy to get published in. Some fellow colleagues in the laboratory have already published many articles.

This is my first time submitting, but I am still taking it seriously and want to live up to its reputation as a Q1 journal.

The submission progress is as follows:

[2021.06.13] Submitted

[2021.06.27] First expert review completed

[2021.07.05] Second expert review completed

[2021.08.04] Received feedback, made revisions, and was accepted. Given three months to make modifications. Both reviews were conducted by the aforementioned two experts. One expert had extremely positive comments, affirming the significance of the research and discussing specific issues. The other reviewer had a very negative attitude, almost saying that the entire paper, from theory and methodology to results, was incorrect. Therefore, during these three months, I addressed the specific points raised by the second expert, conducted additional experiments, and used the experimental results to refute their criticisms.

[2021.10.29] Submitted the revised paper. This time is a bit confusing because since the submission until today, it has been "With Editor," and I don't know if it has been sent for a second expert review.

[2021.11.15] Paper accepted, preparing for publication.

To summarize: The first review of CBM took less than two months and involved only two expert reviewers. As long as the two reviewers do not have simultaneous negative opinions, they should provide an opportunity for revisions. By honestly making revisions, it took less than a month from the second review to acceptance.

I would like to express my gratitude to Letpub for their assistance!

ZHAO J C 2021-11-25

November 13th: Submitted; November 15th: With editor; November 23rd: Under review.

Connor1122 2021-11-25

Submitted 8.26 - Submitted on August 26th
Under review 9.16 - Under review on September 16th
Required Review Completed 10.8 - Required review completed on October 8th
Revision with Justification of Criticisms 10.21 - Revision with justification of criticisms on October 21st
Revised Submitted to Journal 11.6 - Revised submitted to journal on November 6th
Under Review 11.8 - Under review on November 8th
Accepted 11.23 - Accepted on November 23rd

pigwei 2021-11-24

Submission in March.
Return for repair (major revision) in July.
Submit revised manuscript in October.
Accepted in November.
(After major revision, carefully revise again, generally no major problems)