要啥昵称啊 2022-10-10

It has been 7 months, and the first trial has not been completed yet. I am planning to withdraw it.
Earlier, a senior student recommended this journal, and she received a reply in 3 months. It seems that the speed of this journal is quite random.

温吞的蜗牛 2022-09-27

It's better not to invest in special publications. This special publication is very slow, I'm already fed up.

LeeNa 2022-09-27

Is there any formatting requirement when submitting an article to this journal?

cl0wn 2022-09-21

Personally, I speculate that the review speed of this journal is positively correlated with the research direction. The review speed of many papers in abnormal detection/feature detection + machine learning field is relatively fast, while for some smaller or traditional security research directions, the review speed may vary.

I think this journal is still good and suggest evaluating the review speed of articles related to one's own research direction (as mentioned in the articles) before deciding whether to submit.

温吞的蜗牛 2022-09-20

I really envy this kind of speed.

小八月 2022-09-01

The reviewers that this journal found are still quite professional. I submitted the paper in April and received the review comments by the end of June. However, the speed of the editorial processing needs to be urged. The review comments are still very professional and can improve the quality of the paper.

要啥昵称啊 2022-08-29

It's been 6 months and still haven't found a reviewer. The slowness is a bit ridiculous.

Isleak 2022-08-03

May I ask, how long after being hired can I expect to see my work published?

哈哈哈哈 2022-07-29

This journal rejected me directly and did not give me the opportunity to transfer. Later, I submitted to the Journal of Information Security and Applications. The result of the first review came out after two months, and minor revisions were requested. It should be accepted.

要啥昵称啊 2022-07-19

It has been four months since submission, and it has been continuously in the "under review" status. The submission-tracking service shows that no one has accepted the review. It is too slow.

LebronLe 2022-07-18

The review speed of the journal is very fast, and the comments from the reviewers are all positive. One of them directly accepted the article, while others only inquired about time investment. The suggested modifications were also limited to improving visuals and enhancing visualization.

LebronLe 2022-06-16

submitted to journal → with editor for two days → under review for three days, very quickly

费费费德勒 2022-06-10

It took a year and a half for the manuscript to be accepted... Fortunately, it was accepted.

峫峫乐 2022-05-19

Excuse me, did your article get submitted to another journal in the end? Can you please let me know which journal it is? My article's topic is similar to yours.

int_超 2022-05-12

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers usually provide comments for the initial review of this journal? Thank you.

int_超 2022-05-12

Hello, I would like to ask how many reviewers are generally involved in the initial review process for this journal? Is it two or three reviewers?

cl0wn 2022-05-09

May I ask the experienced senior experts, does it affect the peer review process if the email address in the author's submission (second or third work) is filled in incorrectly? Is the confirmation of the author submission important?

小年年 2022-05-05

I want to ask the original poster, how long is "under review"? I have submitted for a month, still "with editor".

Isleak 2022-05-03

I submitted it on 2021.12.21, and until now there have been no revision suggestions. It's too slow.

屁屁飞 2022-04-29

2021. 12.15 Submission
2022. 3.1 Major revision
2022. 3.16 Rework
2022. 4.29 Minor formatting changes
Looking forward to being accepted after the modifications.

哈哈哈哈 2022-04-24

I work in the field of network security, specifically in the area of malicious domain recognition and classification. However, after 4 days, they rejected my paper, claiming that it exceeded the scope of their journal. I'm not sure if it's because my article wasn't good enough or if it truly went beyond their scope. This reason seems quite far-fetched.

哈哈哈哈 2022-03-23

Friend, how is your submission going?

jianjiandandan 2022-02-22

The reviewers that the journal found are very irresponsible. I was conducting a prediction, but they unexpectedly suggested the need to compare with the latest methods from other fields (classification methods). I don't know if they even read it. It is not worth submitting to. It is not unfair for the journal to drop to tier 3.

AuthurYu 2022-01-05

After reviewing for a year, you only give me two suggestions, and reject me. Is that it?

bclsl 2022-01-04

Excuse me, may I ask which research direction you indicated when submitting your paper on artificial intelligence?

kkcharming 2021-12-21

The upgraded version has been downgraded to three regions...

多看论文少吃肉 2021-11-26

The journal's processing speed is quite fast.
Submitted at the end of March.
Received major revisions in early June.
Revised and resubmitted at the end of July.
Received minor revisions based on the second review at the end of September.
Resubmitted at the end of October.
Accepted in mid-November.
Due to being busy halfway through, the review comments on the revised manuscript were slower, otherwise it could have been faster.

TheShine 2021-11-03

Did you reject it or do a major revision? I have also encountered it.

TheShine 2021-11-01

Is it a rejection or a major revision? I have also encountered funny reviewers.

小董不懂 2021-11-01

I think the editing speed is alright, but I feel that the chosen reviewers are very inexplicable. It seems like they are completely talking nonsense, and I don't know what their comments have to do with my article. It also doesn't indicate any problems with my expression. I just feel like the reviewers are pretending to understand without actually understanding. I am very dissatisfied, and I won't submit again in the future.