雪橇狗的咆哮 2022-06-09

It's okay, the opinion is quite fair. The duration of mine is 1.0-2.0 months, which depends on the reviewer's availability.

tbbtbb 2022-06-07

Excuse me, how long is the submission cycle? I submitted on May 13th, and it's still under review. By the way, is this journal reputable?

雪橇狗的咆哮 2022-06-07

I would like to ask if there is anyone else like me. I have been published for several months, but I still cannot be found on Web of Science.

Jackiiiie 2022-05-04

It has become an OA journal, less than 15,000 words. Discuss with the boss before investing, the overall speed is quite fast.

lalalalalalala~ 2022-05-03

Hello, may I ask if this journal has already become an Open Access (OA) journal? Can I choose a non-OA method to publish my paper?

SCU成勇 2022-03-31

So far, as of June 2021, the submission was made, and a reviewer was assigned for a major revision. Immediately after the response, the submission was rejected due to a high rate of repetition. Upon investigating the reason, it was found that the repetition was due to a preprint issue. An email was sent to the editor-in-chief to appeal and explain the situation. The editor-in-chief agreed to give it another chance and assigned one reviewer. After the response, it was sent for review by two reviewers. This process went back and forth three times, lasting for six months. It was the longest and most painful experience in the author's submission career. Multiple revisions were made repeatedly, but the final reviewer still disagreed with publication, while one agreed to accept it. The editor-in-chief ignored the disagreement and chose to accept it.

Jackiiiie 2022-02-26

The translation of "编辑是期刊分配的" from Chinese to English is "Editing is assigned by the journal."

强强浙江大学 2022-02-25

Hello, may I ask if you are responsible for editing your article, Duc Long Nghiem?

Jackiiiie 2022-02-25

Overall, the process was fast, and the reviewers were quite nice. They provided professional and targeted suggestions, and I put a lot of effort into addressing the nearly 15 pages of revisions. After major revisions, the paper was accepted directly.

Submitted--Dec 04, 2021
With Editor--Dec 05, 2021
Under Review--Dec 11, 2021
Major Revision-- Dec 30, 2021
Revision Submitted--Feb 15, 2022
Under Review--Feb 16, 2022
Accepted--Feb 24, 2022

仰对昭昭 2021-12-28

The review comments from the journal are very fair and good. However, the speed is not very fast, which may be related to different editors.

科研小白 2021-12-27

I submitted it in May this year, and it has been almost 8 months now. After the major revision and second review, it has been more than 1 month with the status "decision in process". What's going on? Why is the "decision in process" taking so long? I pray that it can be accepted smoothly.

xxyyy 2021-12-08

Excuse me, how long did you continue with the editor?

! 2021-10-26

9.2 with editor
9.25 under review
10.15 Being revised by the author
10.23 Submit revised draft
10.24 Accepted

! 2021-09-19

How could it be so slow? Submitted on September 2, 2021. Reviewed by the editor on September 3. It has been over half a month and it is still in the hands of the editor now.

CQU成勇 2021-09-02

It will soon become open source, can't accept it, be cautious when investing!!!

We are delighted to announce that from January 2022, Environmental Technology & Innovation will become a gold open access journal with no subscription charges. As we transition to becoming a gold open access journal, the Article Processing Charge (APC) will be implemented for accepted articles with an original submission date after October 1, 2021. The APC for Environmental Technology & Innovation is US$ 2400 (excluding taxes).

拉格朗日中值定理 2021-08-23

This journal's editorial team processes things very quickly. During the first review, there was a delay because one reviewer took almost two months to review, which caused a time delay. Otherwise, it wouldn't have taken more than three months. Although this journal is in the third tier, it has an impact factor of 5.26, so there is a good chance it will move up to the second tier.

xie多多 2021-08-17

Here is a summary of my own experience regarding the "Decision in process" status.

※ If this status appears after the initial submission with the editor, there is a high probability that the paper will be rejected. However, the editor is not entirely certain and would consult the editorial team to make a decision. Regardless of the final outcome, the editor will provide more suggestions, which can be considered as a benefit.

※ If this status appears after the initial review under review, it depends on the journal. In top-tier journals, it may indicate that the reviewer's comments are not favorable. Based on personal and others' experiences, out of approximately four instances, only one paper was not rejected, mainly because one reviewer recommended major revisions. In other journals, this status may be a normal part of the process and does not necessarily indicate positive or negative comments from the reviewers.

※ If this status appears after the second or third review under review during the revision process, it is part of the regular process and is unrelated to the specific reviewer comments.

The above is solely a summary of my personal experience. If there are any inaccuracies, I welcome everyone's guidance and exchange of knowledge!

xie多多 2021-08-17

No, after the under review stage of this journal, the decision in process will not automatically appear. This is the situation I am in, and I was extremely anxious when I saw it go directly from under review to decision in process. However, after one hour, it turned out to be a major revision result. When I submitted to other journals before, after the under review stage, there was a "with editor" status, and then I was given a major revision. There were also instances where it stayed as decision in process for several days, and ultimately, my submission was rejected. So, I feel that the decision in process status can vary among different journals.

lalalalyuuu 2021-08-01

May I ask, what happens after "Decision in Process" appears directly after you submit for review? Is it necessary to continue making modifications?

如梦 2021-06-20

Feeling that editing is so difficult! Isn't it exaggerated?

如梦 2021-06-20

It's really slow, my goodness!

shgj 2021-05-09

Hello, may I ask what else is needed after the major repairs, and how long will it take to receive the news?

shgj 2021-05-09

Hello, may I ask if your article needs to be sent for external review after the major revision? How long will it take to receive a response?

Sun 2021-04-27

Excuse me, is the number of articles in this journal so few because they are invited contributions? Or is it simply a low circulation?

提笔绘江山 2021-03-15

Do you have the status "Decision in Process"?

提笔绘江山 2021-03-15

Hello, why does my application show "Decision in Process" immediately after submission? Does this mean it's going to be rejected?

提笔绘江山 2021-03-15

Does the appearance of "Decision in Process" directly after two months of submission for Environmental Technology & Innovation mean that it will be rejected?

红萝卜头 2021-03-15

Hello, I submitted my application at the end of November last year. On December 6th, it changed to "under review" and it has remained in this status until now. The status time has not changed either. May I ask what is the current situation? Is it still under review?

aalbxy 2021-03-04

How many days does it take for the submission to reach the editor's hands? It's been almost a week for me as well.

aalbxy 2021-03-04

Why haven't I received any response for a week after submitting to the journal? When did it reach the editor's hands at your end?